Why we must let the facts lead the story

Police vanplaceholder image
Police van | Oli Woodman

As police continue their investigation into Anne Widdecombe's death, this tragedy serves as a reminder of why evidence must always come before opinion

Tragically Haytor is now on the national news with the alleged murder of Anne Widdecombe.

Initially the police said there was no evidence of a political or terrorist motivation, but new evidence has come to light suggesting this may not be the case.

In the world of social media the police have a problem. How much information should be made available to the public? In the awful case of the stabbing of the young girls at a Taylor Swift party in Southport, the police did not release many details. This led to riots outside hotels housing immigrants after false conspiracy theories appeared online. The crime was not committed by an illegal immigrant.

Because of this case and others, soon after Anne Widdecombe’s death the police gave a statement discussing the investigation. When they said, “there is no evidence this was a terrorist incident or had a political motive at this time”, I am sure they were correct. At first this might have been a botched burglary. What was less reported was the next line, “We are keeping an open mind”. It was only as the investigation progressed that a possible political or terrorist motive became clear.

Although I have no details of the investigation, before anyone criticises the police for initially suggesting that this terrible crime was not politically motivated, our Devon and Cornwall Police showed remarkable forensic skills in locating a suspect in Yorkshire.

The police also warned against speculation although this did not stop some politicians. In all legal cases speculation is not helpful. They also warned that it could upset the family. Only the police have the full facts. Conspiracy theories online risk a miscarriage of justice or even the guilty walking free.

To give an example away from this tragic case, suppose a key witness in a burglary had seen and recognised a burglar but then a video appeared online of a figure climbing out of the window. The defence barrister could argue that seeing the video had influenced the witness. The judge could then rule this evidence inadmissible.

The “mainstream media” get criticised by the keyboard warriors but they have to walk a difficult tightrope. All professional journalists will have studied media law and are aware of the dangers. Stories can be spun to fit a narrative but every “fact” must have evidence. Any possible contempt of court or false allegation which could lead to legal action will be looked at in detail by the lawyers before publication.

When Steven Yaxley-Lennon, who calls himself Tommy Robinson, was charged with contempt of court after filming the accused outside Canterbury Crown Court and calling them “Muslim Child Rapists”, he may have believed that he was fighting for free speech but it could have led to all of them walking free.

First impressions at a crime scene can be misleading. When I was working as a police surgeon whenever the police were called to a body I was called out. Then the law said that only a doctor could confirm death or, as a colleague once commented, “you’re not dead until I tell you”.

One night I was called to a body outside a dairy which was then in Waterleat Road, Paignton. It was dark and raining. There was a body lying across a concrete slab. We all agreed that the wounds were consistent with a fall. Perhaps he was drunk. The investigation proved us wrong. He had failed to pay his drug dealers who had beaten him up. This is why it is important to keep an open mind. As the body was found by a dairy the police called the case “Operation Frisian”.

Another aspect of the tragic case of Anne Widdecombe was the response. Most people, whatever their politics, were sad and horrified. Sadly there were some who did not like her views and made highly offensive comments. To use a Voltaire quote which he probably never said, “I disapprove of what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”

Anne Widdecombe was a sincere Roman Catholic with deeply held beliefs. They may have been very different from mine but I still have the utmost respect for her as a person.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice