Opinion: why Torquay's £70m harbour hotel decision matters more than one building


Torbay Weekly Editor, Jim Parker, talks on why Torquay's £70m hotel decision is about more than one site
Let battle commence as plans to build a six-storey, 144-bedroom hotel on Torquay harbourside reach a crucial stage - planning.
Torbay’s planning committee meets on Wednesday to deliberate on a 150-page report to decide on the £70 million to demolish the former Debenham store and buildings alongside it and replace it with a four-star hotel with rooftop bar.
The scheme also includes commercial spaces to the ground floor and a ‘stepped street’ between The Strand and The Terrace behind.
Conservationists and campaigners are already making their feelings known, concerned that a large chunk of Torquay’s harbourside history will come crashing down with the buildings.
But, hugely important as it is in isolation, is there much more at stake here?
The scheme is being submitted by developers Willmott Dixon who, together with Milligan, are the private sector partners with Torbay Council and who are tasked with a massive regeneration programme to find investors to transform a dozen or so key sites around the Bay which will shape our future for years to come.
There is no intent of blackmail here, but what message would a knock-back from planners to the harbour hotel project give to those people with money in their wallets looking to invest in that future.
Officers are recommending that the scheme should go ahead. A report says to the planning committee: “The planning balance section has weighed the public benefits against the level of harm identified and has concluded that the adverse impacts of the proposed development do not outweigh the public benefits.
“Due to the level of accordance with the Development Plan and in the absence of material considerations that weigh sufficiently against the proposal, the Officer recommendation is one of approval, subject to suitable planning conditions and the required contributions.
“The proposed development is considered to represent sustainable development and is acceptable, having regard to the Local Plan, the Neighbourhood Plan, the NPPF, and all other material considerations.”
Chris Lewis, Torbay Council deputy leader and Conservative councillor in charge of regeneration, revealed the plans include the retention of the facade of the Grade Two listed former Bank of Scotland building.
Cllr Lewis said: “We are doing what we can to keep the historic part of The Strand.”
But he added: “We have to move forward. We cannot have delays with people thinking about it. We have had public consultations. This is what we have had in Torbay over a number of years. People have to get on with it.
“We have to start making decisions on projects that will be good for the Bay. That was in our manifesto when we were first elected.
“With the likes of the Pavilion, Oldway and the Paignton Picture House and historic buildings Torbay has a record second to none over the past 20 years.
“This is the really big one. This is the one that matters the most of all the projects.
“We want political buy-in so that investors can see that Torbay means business.
“This is the vital one. It is what people want to see when they come to Torbay.
“We need planning permission. Nobody will invest without planning.”
He revealed: “There are hotel chains being talked to and investors lined up. Everybody is waiting for planning. That is why it is so important that we get cross party support.”
The planning application details the proposed development site as 7, 7A, 8, 9, 10, 10A, 11, 11A, 12, 13 and 14 The Strand and 43, 45, 47 And 55, 57, 59 The Terrace.
It comprises several commercial units, the majority of which are now vacant. The site is situated in between Hoopers Department Store (Nos.5-6 The Strand) and Yates (Nos.15-16 The Strand).
The units within the site include the following: No.7 The Strand – Formerly Maggie & Co, a boutique clothing store, which has been vacant for a few years. No.8 The Strand – Formerly the Royal Bank of Scotland, which is a Grade II listed building and has been vacant since 2018/2019. No.9 The Strand – Currently occupied by Taco Bell. No.10-10A, 11-11A, 12-14 The Strand – Formerly Debenhams, a department store, which has been vacant for a few years. A small bridal boutique was included within the frontage known as Jane’s which has recently relocated to another unit in Torquay Town Centre. Nos.55, 57 and 59 The Terrace – A building block containing 3no. residential apartments set back behind No.11-11A The Strand.
There is an associated listed building consent application for alterations to No.8 The Strand which is the Grade Two listed old bank building but its facade will be retained.
At the time of writing 21 letters of objection and nine letters of support have been received. Four letters of objection are from the Torbay Heritage Trust.
Comments for the project include: It provides facilities It removes an eyesore Makes tourist facilities better It makes highway matters better It’s shown in the Local Plan Provides/retains jobs Sets precedent Residential amenity Design Economic benefits Regeneration benefits
Those against include: Impact on the local area Not in keeping with the local area Sets precedent Noise and disturbance including anti-social behaviour Overdevelopment Residential amenity Impact on heritage assets including listed buildings and conservation area Design/visual impact/building height/massing/scale Loss of light Privacy/overlooking Trees and wildlife Viability Traffic and access including manoeuvrability of service vehicles and lack of parking provision Impact on existing tourist accommodation Landscaping management Sustainable transport access
According to the report, the Torquay Neighbourhood Forum Steering Group is supportive of the ‘principle’ of the redevelopment and construction of a hotel and retail premises.
It says: “This is long overdue after the closure of Debenhams, and fulfils the major aspirations cited in the Torquay Neighbourhood Plan to celebrate and enhance both the vibrancy and uniqueness of Torquay town centre and harbour front, and the shopping and social experience related to the newly upgraded harbour public realm.”
But they expressed concerns over the increase in height of the development which ‘overwhelms the neighbouring buildings, and destroys the current vista of the Terrace, which was built in the early 19th Century, and became a key feature of the view from the harbour’
The Forum even mentions Sir Lawrence Palk who built the grade II listed houses on 'The Terrace' that lie above and behind the development site in 1811 to designs by Jacob Harvey. “They are one of the earliest architectural set pieces of Torquay and create "an elegant terrace [which is] historically important in the development of Torquay.
“These were designed to have primacy in views to and from the harbour and represent the start of Torquay's transformation from its origins as a small fishing village to a holiday destination.”
They also raised concerns about noise, light pollution, traffic traffic movements and intrusion into the privacy of all those living on the Terrace.
The Forum concludes: “Overall, the Forum supports the principle of the development but, like Historic England, some changes are needed for us to offer full support.”
Torbay Council’s Principal Strategy & Project Management Officer says in the report that the principle of tourism-led regeneration is ‘strongly supported in this location’.
The officer adds: “The proposal would have significant regeneration and economic benefits.” That would include creating millions for the local economy and hundreds of new jobs.”
The officer concludes: “There is strong policy support for the proposal, which would regenerate an important part of Torquay town centre and would be an important element in the modernisation of the tourism economy and Torquay town centre. The proposal is very sustainably sited for a hotel and is within the CTIA (core tourism area). I note that the proposal generates significant design, massing and heritage issues. These must be given great weight but should be balanced with the regeneration benefits of the proposal.”
Historic England said it supports the principle of the regeneration of this part of Torquay's historic core, but it has concerns about the heritage impacts of the proposals.
“We consider that relatively modest adjustments to the scheme could successfully address several of these concerns and successfully balance the redevelopment of the site with the conservation of Torquay's special historic qualities,” it says in the report.
Devon County Council’s County Archaeologist & Historic Environment Manager talks of some potential for archaeological remains at the site. Concern is also expressed about the creation of a ‘large, blocky appearance’ with the new building.
And finally, the planning officers assessment says: “The public benefits in the form of the economic, social and environmental include the regeneration of a key harbourside location where several buildings have been vacant and underutilised for many years.
“This will result in a key driver of economic growth in terms of construction and post-construction employment and expenditure.
“The proposed development would assist in revitalising Torquay Town Centre including introducing new commercial units, additional facilities and amenities for both residents and visitors of Torbay. The proposal would result in enhanced public realm and accessibility within Torquay Town Centre that would have a wider public benefit.”
So, over to you councillors. Nobody wants to see Torquay’s history go down the pan, but we have to make old work with new with these redevelopment projects. We simply cannot stand still without a Plan B…..