Strand decision raises questions that won’t go away

Sally Allen - Chair of Torbay Civic Societyplaceholder image
Sally Allen - Chair of Torbay Civic Society | Sally Allen

The redevelopment of the Strand will shape Torquay’s waterfront for generations. While regeneration is widely welcomed, questions persist over design, heritage, economics and the way concerns were addressed during the planning process

Last week, I attended the planning committee meeting where the massive decision was to be made regarding the redevelopment of the Strand. Huge development and therefore a huge and significant decision. The outcome is going to be with us, or rather the Bay as I certainly won’t be here, for possibly a hundred years, so it was clearly something that had to have very careful thought and consideration.

I have to admit that there is so much I don’t ‘get’ about this committee, including how the members get chosen and what their genuine experience is for making such far-reaching decisions.

Sadly, the outcome of the meeting and final decision saw the planning committee even ignore the Council’s own planning rules as well as, I understand, ignoring the Victorian Society, Historic England, The Georgian Group, and Save Britain’s Heritage, all of whom have expressed serious concerns about the Council’s handling of this application, including correspondence that has gone unanswered or advice that has been disregarded.

It appears the normal process of the Council is to ask for input from the community and then completely ignore it. The Hotel Indigo had over 500 objections and it is indisputable that the ‘overlooking and noise’ to Cromartie Point is appalling, but it was passed by planning.

Following the decision of the Supreme Court in Fearn and others vs Board of Trustees of Tate Gallery (2023), there is no doubt that residents of Cromartie Point would have been awarded compensation for the overlooking, etc. However, the cost of litigation was prohibitive for the residents.

Make no mistake, I am very much in favour of the redevelopment of the Strand site, but don’t believe that the current design fits with its surroundings in the middle of a marine conservation area. In fact, it creates ‘harm’ and destroys the ‘character and appearance’ of the harbour area as there is no attempt for it to blend into the once celebrated and beautiful natural environment.

Added to this, it is far too tall at the Debenhams end, so it blocks the beautiful vista of the Grade II listed Terrace, built in 1811 – a focal point of Torbay for a couple of centuries. It will also bring ‘significant harm’ to the Grade II Landmark Terrace and No. 8, the Bank Grade II listed building, even though they intend to keep the façade, because the Grade II pitched roof is to be replaced by an additional storey flat roof.

Then there is the noise level for surrounding residents from the proposed ‘Sky’ bar and restaurant which we know will be excessive and bring a highly negative impact on the road infrastructure and create a major adverse visual impact of the Terrace viewed from the harbour. Plus, the parking of delivery lorries, etc., will cause chaos on the already overburdened Terrace.

All things considered, you would think that the planning committee would ask the architects to go back to the drawing board to amend their plans. That wasn’t even discussed.

I am now going to quote directly from Councillor Cordelia Law’s objection, which again was sadly ignored in its entirety.

“As one of the ward councillors, let me be clear from the outset: No one is opposing the idea of regeneration. But regeneration should never be a by-word for wholesale demolition and inappropriate development. True regeneration respects the unique character, heritage and economy of an area and serves the long-term interests of residents. In its current form, this application absolutely fails to do this.

“I won’t dwell on the negative heritage impacts on our harbour conservation area; you should have already read the very strong objections from the national heritage organisations, as well as the disappointment of Historic England and the Council’s own heritage officer, that their concerns have not been sufficiently addressed.

“Under Section 66 and 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, as well as NPPF Section 16, you have a statutory duty to give great weight to preserving our heritage assets. The only grounds for such harm to the setting of heritage assets and conservation areas is when there are public and economic benefits that far outweigh the harm caused.

“You are being asked to approve permanent and irreversible harm to Torquay’s harbour conservation area; however, a critical examination of the economic justification to balance that harm shows that this proposal totally fails this fundamental statutory planning balance test.

“So, let’s look at the economic justification for the destruction of 17 buildings in the heart of our conservation area; the economic assessment submitted projects the wages and GVA over 60 years, which is highly unusual. So, to make it more relatable, I’ll break some down to annually.

“The first ground for refusal is the mistake in the calculations of the construction phase benefits. After applying the cited multiplier and additionality formula to the stated 367 gross direct person years of employment, it should yield 301 net person years and not the 533 claimed in the economic assessment. This, of course, also renders the anticipated wages and GVA incorrect.

“You cannot pass this application based on construction benefits that you know are incorrect.

“Furthermore, the economic justification claims variously in the document that the operational phase will create 163 Gross direct FTE jobs and £1.6m wages pa. Yet elsewhere, it states, and I quote: ‘The hotel will support approximately 115 gross direct FTE jobs. These jobs will generate £66m in wages …’ Again, that’s over 60 years, so just £1.1m per year. So, net, that’s 89 or 63 jobs at just £9,500 pa. That can’t be accurate as it is below minimum wage?

“The assessment envisages 50% displacement from the operational phase, which means that 50% of the hotel’s business will be taken away from existing businesses. That is not regeneration. That is economic vandalism of our already struggling hospitality sector.

“Another questionable figure is the quote that the development has the potential to attract 85,610 visitors a year. It sounds great, but for the hotel to attract and hence accommodate that many new visitors, they would need a staggering 80% plus occupancy, 365 days a year.

“That seems incredibly ambitious to me. Especially when you consider that the Fragrance Group’s justification for not rebuilding the Palace hotel was a lack of viability and an overestimation of the demand for exactly this type of accommodation.

“Viability for this development is impossible to assess, due to the lack of relevant information, but the National Audit Office estimates cost for this type of development to lie between £250-£350,000 per room. This development will cost £486,000 and just over half a million pounds per room. That should concern you greatly.

“All these things are valid grounds for refusal. You cannot approve such harm to the historic environment, based on inaccurate yet still negligible economic benefits. That contravenes the NPPF and would constitute valid grounds for a judicial review.

“We’ve been here before with Torquay Pavilion; let’s demonstrate that we’ve learnt that lesson and refuse this application today.”

Were any of Cordelia’s excellent and pertinent points discussed or considered? Well, not from where I was sitting, and yet clearly the sums don’t even add up!

Very importantly, who sits on the ‘Design Review Panel’ and are there any conflicts of interest? Why does the Council appear to dismiss any constructive criticism or concerns put forward from people and organisations far more experienced and knowledgeable than anyone who sits on the committees?

At the very least, listen, consider and try to understand different points of view before charging off into the very expensive abyss with taxpayers’ or investors’ money. This redevelopment has to work and be something that future generations can be proud of, not another white elephant.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice