Devon’s new future, Labour’s gamble and a farewell to Ann Widdecombe


Nick Bye reflects on local government reorganisation, Labour’s decision to replace Sir Keir Starmer, and the life and legacy of Ann Widdecombe
There are three topics this week which I hope Mr Editor will allow me to cover:
First, we now have the government's plan for the reorganisation of local government in Devon which, surprise, surprise, is exactly what I forecast in these pages about twelve months ago. Perhaps I should apply for a job as a political pundit.
It was bound to be the case the government would listen most closely to proposals from Plymouth & Exeter, both of which are places with Labour MPs & Labour-led councils. When they put forward their proposals last summer for an expanded Plymouth unitary council & a new unitary council for Exeter & surrounding area, extending to Dawlish & Exmouth, I guessed it was with the government's blessing & this is what we would end up with. From memory, it was their suggestion Torbay should expand its boundaries to include the neighbouring South Hams villages such as Kingswear, Stoke Gabriel & Marldon; also the more urban areas of Teignbridge including Newton Abbot, Kingsteignton & Teignmouth.
Given the government started off by stating they wanted to see new unitary councils with populations of 500,000 plus, this is a very modest expansion indeed for Torbay. Basically, we shall be about half as big again as we are now, although with lots of building underway around Newton Abbot & more to come, the likelihood is we shall end up with a population of about 240/250,000 before too long. This has long been considered a viable size for a unitary council. It should provide us with the capacity to "get things done".
Most of the new areas are relatively prosperous & certainly none with the scale of multiple deprivation which blights parts of Torquay & Paignton. I welcome the government's decision & just hope we all now work together to make a success of these opportunities.
There is some suggestion the new Coast & Country unitary council to cover the remaining largely rural areas of Devon might struggle & folk there have been "sold down the river".
The reality is in Wiltshire & Dorset the major urban areas have long been separated from the rural areas; rural Wiltshire & Dorset have long-established track records as successful unitary councils, whereas Bournemouth/Christchurch/Poole & Swindon, like Torbay, have had their fair share of ups & downs.
The second hot topic to reflect upon is the installation of our next new Prime Minister, the sixth since the Brexit referendum (since when our politics have become a bit bonkers).
It does seem remarkable to me Labour MPs decided to ditch their leader & Prime Minister just two years after delivering a landslide general election victory. To put this in perspective, only three Labour leaders before Sir Keir Starmer have achieved an overall majority in the hundred or so years since Labour became a contender for power: Clement Attlee, Harold Wilson & Tony Blair.
Their first Prime Minister, Ramsay MacDonald, only held office with the support of other parties; Jim Callaghan & Gordon Brown took over when Labour was already in power & subsequently lost the following general election. There have been no other Labour Prime Ministers. Keir Starmer is their seventh & Andy Burnham will be their eighth.
My hunch is history will judge this as (another) moment of madness. Sir Keir Starmer, in simple terms, has been a disappointment rather than a disaster, quite effective on the world stage although only making slow progress on the domestic front. He has behaved with decency & dignity over the last few weeks & came across very well at his final Prime Minister's Questions last week.
Even if Labour MPs wanted a new leader to take them into the next general election, I believe Sir Keir should have been given a little more time in office. Continually swapping leaders didn't do my lot much good.
If Andy Burnham pursues very different policies, for example more nationalisation & higher taxes, then there will be very legitimate arguments made about the lack of a democratic mandate. If he carries on with the same policies, then what is the point of his coup?
Finally, I was so very sorry to hear of the death of Ann Widdecombe, apparently murdered at her home close to Haytor.
It was just such an awful ending of a life of a person who was a genuine "one-off" who made forthright contributions to political debate, served as an MP & Government Minister, then in later years entertained us (& herself) through all her television appearances & writing.
I had the privilege of hosting Ann at a large dinner for the Conservative Association, at the Imperial Hotel, about twelve years ago. Even now people talk about how she "went round" on a positive whirlwind tour, speaking to guests at every table & answering questions on showbusiness & politics with equal aplomb.
She had just completed her "Strictly" season, had published a memoir & was only too delighted to set up a stall & sell her books. She kindly donated the proceeds & offered the name of a character in her next book for auction, which made serious money.
In June 2023 I escorted Ann through the streets of Oxford as we made our way from the gardens of the Oxford Union to the magnificent Town Hall for a celebration dinner to commemorate 200 years of this famous debating society & free speech.
Only those who had held office were invited to attend, with one exception. As Michael Crick explained to me, Philip May (who had been a charming President of the Union in our time) asked if he could bring his wife?
Ann Widdecombe was all about free speech, the cut & thrust of debate, so it's fitting this last encounter was in such a setting. She will be much missed & all our lives have become a bit more drab.
Best wishes,
Nick Bye