Peter Moore: Are footballers really as ‘dim’ as the stereotype?


Peter Moore argues that modern day football is now much more of a mind game
At a news conference when Peter Shilton was manager of Plymouth Argyle Football Club, he said: “We’re going to rise up like a pheasant from the ashes.”
“Don’t you mean Phoenix?” asked a journalist.
“I knew it began with an F.”
Although the story may be apocryphal it is not surprising that the image of footballers is not one of academic brilliance. But is this fair?
When David Beckham played for AC Milan and went for a meal with a journalist he spoke Italian to the waiter.
“Why don’t you speak Italian in public?” he was asked.
“Because my Italian is not perfect. If I make any mistakes the press will hammer me.”
The idea that Beckham could speak Italian did not fit in with the narrative of a “stupid footballer”.
There are plenty of examples of very bright players. The past England player Graeme le Saux took an environmental degree at university before dropping out to play football.
Bukayo Saka, the England and Arsenal player, achieved high grades in GCSE, including three As and four A*s. I remember a Torquay United player who had a sports science degree. And love or hate Gary Lineker, he is obviously intelligent.
I know someone who played semi-professional football in the National League South, the same level as Torquay. He was part time, also working as a maths teacher. He had a good degree. Several football league teams had approached him but he enjoyed his job and was playing football at a good level. At one time he was earning more from football than teaching. Why give this up to play in the lower levels of the football league?
So, is the popular image of the dim footballer wrong? In the past the game was simple. Boot the ball up the pitch and run. Today professional football is more like three-dimensional chess. Professional footballers have to be able to problem solve, assessing the situation and reacting quickly under pressure. A goalkeeper must read the game well ahead of any shot. A defender must see the run of the attacker, anticipate his next move and be aware of the position of his teammates. Midfielders have to plan where to pass, anticipating the actions of the defence and his own players.
Recent research from Sweden studied 200 professional footballers in Brazil and Sweden. I apologise that I will refer to all players as “he” but the research was carried out with male players. Women footballers have a different image and no one sees the Lionesses as dim.
In tests for cognition, problem solving and using memory quickly to plan action, the footballers scored very highly, placing them in the top one or two per cent.
Although they did not test specifically for IQ this is probably the equivalent of IQs between 120 and 130.
How did the myth begin that they are all stupid? Potential top-level players concentrate on football from an early age. Although attempts are being made to ensure school age players receive an all-round education it is inevitable that academic studies get neglected.
They may also be less articulate. Not knowing about the phoenix rising from the ashes might just reflect a poor education rather than lack of intelligence.
We also have to look at the history of association football. The game was invented in Victorian public schools. The public-school boys were fitter, bigger and better fed than the sons of the working class.
As it is a game based on skill and not just brute force once the working-class boys started playing, they beat the public school boys. Clearly this was not acceptable to the elite and so they changed to rugby, which did require brawn. Even now rugby is seen as a posher game than soccer.
Of course, not every football player could join Mensa. As in any profession, some are brighter than others but to be a top professional player requires a type of intelligence. Knowing how to spell phoenix and pheasant is not the only measure of intelligence.
Will footballers be over the moon when they realise that their head is not just for heading the ball?