Jim Parker: Why did our fish and chips bid get battered - and will it be third time lucky?


Councillors and officers are still trying to come to terms with Torbay's latest 'fish and chips' bid for government funding being battered. The government refused to back the resort's Levelling Up bid - Torbay had asked for £20 million to expand Brixham
Councillors and officers are still trying to come to terms with Torbay's latest 'fish and chips' bid for government funding being battered.
The government refused to back the resort's Levelling Up bid - Torbay had asked for £20 million to expand Brixham’s fishing market and build an electronics and photonics production facility at Torbay Business Park.
The council claims both projects would have created more than 200 new jobs and raked in £56 million for the local economy.
Having failed to win a share of Westminster cash at the first attempt, Torbay’s efforts were again thwarted in the second round after being reportedly advised to submit the same bid .
Brixham councillor and cabinet member Mike Morey is annoyed at the government’s decision.
“We saw it as a kick in the teeth to the fishing industry and the local economy to be honest. It appears that most of the successful Levelling Up bids went to the south east, which was a bit concerning.”
The projects were aimed at capitalising on the potential growth of the two sectors leading to more employment opportunities and anticipated private investment.
The application had been supported by both local MPs and more widely across the community, including the Torbay Together partnership, representing partners from the business, public and community sectors.
The Government revealed more than 100 projects are to share £2.1billion from round two of the fund. Successful bids include almost £50million for rail improvements in Cornwall, £15.7million to improve the Exmouth Gateway transport hub and £18.2million to help transform Bournemouth and Poole seafront. Weymouth and Weston-super-Mare have each received £19million for harbourside and tourism projects.
Anthony Mangnall, MP for Brixham and parts of Paignton, said: "It is disappointing to learn that Torbay has not been successful. However, there will be a third round and we will ensure that an updated strong bid is put forward that represents the very best of Brixham, the fishing sector and our rising photonics industry.
"South Devon’s economy has seen high levels of investment, another record breaking year for Brixham Fish Market and greater opportunities for the photonics sector. This geographical area and these sectors offer huge potential to create new jobs and boost the local economy.
"Together with Torbay Council, we will continue to support this unique and special area."
Torbay MP Kevin Foster said: “I am disappointed to hear the bid submitted by Torbay Council has not succeeded. Anthony and I will be meeting to identify what we can do as local MPs to ensure the necessary work is done locally to ensure a future bid succeeds.
“We will shortly meet with Government Ministers to identify if there were specific areas of concern which need to be addressed and what, if any, impact delays in Torbay Council getting work underway on other schemes where significant Government funding has been made available had on this decision.”
The blow came just as a new report - in which Torbay played a major part compiling - concluded that seaside resorts like the English Riviera urgently needed long-term government funding.
The report called Communities on the Edge said ministers must do more to help struggling coastal communities around England with levelling-up policies at risk of failing to turnaround decades of inequality.
See if any of these findings ring true for the Bay:
* Nearly one in five jobs pay below the living wage.
*Household income is almost £3,000 lower than in non-coastal areas.
*There are poorer health, education, transport and broadband links.
* Many areas have lower wages due to jobs being seasonal and part-time in the tourism sector, or with small firms.
*A lower proportion of children achieve GCSE qualifications in maths and English, with children more likely to regularly miss school.
*Fewer council houses mean people rely on private rentals where costs are higher, and cars are needed because of poor public transport.
*Coastal areas have higher rates of depression, suicide, alcohol-related hospital admissions and emergency admissions for lung conditions.
The report was commissioned by the Coastal Communities Alliance, the Local Government Association Coastal Special Interest Group and the Coastal Partnerships Network.
It warns levelling up's focus on regions means "massive challenges" faced by some smaller, remote parts of the country are "hidden" and likely to be missed by the government.
Former mayor and Wellswood councillor Nick Bye has table a question to full council concerned the dumped Bay bid did not meet the correct criteria.
His question says: "Levelling Up Funds were available according to the relevant government website under three separate headings or themes; Developing Better Transport Links; Revitalising Towns and Cities specifically "regeneration in town centres (to) unlock thousands of new homes"; and Restoring Local Heritage.
Again from the government website "The Levelling Up Fund is designed to invest in infrastructure that improves every day life across the UK. The fund will support town centre and high street regeneration, local transport projects, and cultural and heritage assets."
"Could the Leader of the Council please advise which of these three headings or themes the Torbay "fish & chips" bid for funding for the Brixham Fish Quay & Photonics business centre at Long Road came under?"
Council leader Steve Darling insisted: "We were given strong encouragement to put forward the first bid again. Since then we have had a merry-go-round of different ministers in post.
"The thinking has changed significantly. Otherwise one would have expected to get it over the line.
"20 per cent of all bids were not funded. It was a tough situation. Whatever colour government is in power you to need to know the music being played so you can then dance to it.
"Since the bid was put in there has been a massive change to what we were told was good to go. What was awarded this time was around culture and transport which was different to the bid we were told would be successful.
The money went to the most marginal seats."
He added: "We have been asked to bid for funding for a new walking and cycling initiative. We have been given 12 days to bid. A quality bid takes 12 weeks. The coastal communities report says that places like Torbay have massive potential but it needs unleashing and that is by long-term financial funding and not a series of gimmicks."
Will there a third bid from the Bay and will it be changed?
Cllr Darling said politely: "We just need to be led by what the government priorities are."
Exmouth, Weymouth, Weston-super-mare, Bournemouth and Poole. It does seem we have missed our this time and big time at that.
Fingers and anything else you can cross for third time lucky!