Dr Peter Moore: Here's hoping mental health services concentrate their minds on 'Right Care, Right Person'

placeholder image

The Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Sir Mark Rowley, has announced that they will not attend emergency calls for mental health issues after August 31 unless there is a threat to life. These should be handled by experts in mental health. Many people we

The Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Sir Mark Rowley, has announced that they will not attend emergency calls for mental health issues after August 31 unless there is a threat to life.

These should be handled by experts in mental health.

Many people were shocked but having worked with the police as a police surgeon and their clinical consultant, my reaction was 'here we go again'.

However caring and well meaning, the police are the wrong people to pick up the pieces from a failing mental health service.

In England and Wales officers spend almost a million hours a year in A&E departments with people waiting for mental health assessments. These officers are needed on the streets.

Under the Mental Health Act, a police officer can remove anyone to a 'place of safety' if they are in a public place, appear to the officer to be suffering from a mental illness and are a danger to themselves or others.

The place of safety can be a police station or a hospital.

I was once called to an elderly lady in Torquay police station. She got off the train in Torquay, walked across to a hotel and told the receptionist she was booked in.

“I can’t see your name here, madam,” the receptionist replied.

“I must be,” she said, “the queen booked me in personally.”

It was then that the receptionist realised that this poor old lady was mentally unwell. After a fruitless attempt to contact social services eventually she called the police. The young officer was also stuck. In the end, his only option was to take her to the police station as a place of safety.

I saw her in the police station which was full of swearing aggressive drunks. She was wearing twin set and pearls muttering about how she couldn’t understand what happened. “I know the Queen booked me in.”

We all agreed that the whole situation was completely wrong. After some research, the sergeant discovered she had come from a residential home in Notting Hill, London. Somehow, she had walked to Paddington, got on a train and got off at Torquay.

When our sergeant rang the Notting Hill police station they were busy. It was the weekend of the Notting Hill Carnival.

Eventually, with the help of our social services liaising with the Notting Hill services, we managed to get her home.

I also saw people who were suicidal locked in a cell waiting for a mental health assessment. It felt Victorian.

But arguments over mentally unwell people in the police station is not new.

The British Medical Journal of October 1884 reported that when a 'lunatic' came into police custody medical practitioners in Exeter found themselves in an 'awkward predicament'.

“The mayor thinks that the lunacy laws are imperfect... If he think fit, he orders any medical man... to examine a patient alleged to be insane; ...he apparently considers that the holding of such examinations is a part of the public duty which a doctor must perform, for he is reported to have threatened to indict a medical man who refused to examine a patient when bidden, and, on the other hand, to have declined to pay for an examination held by a practitioner whom he had called.”

There is no mention of the role of the police but doubtless they were caught in the crossfire.

Although I have not worked with the police for 10 years, sadly it seems that the situation in London has not changed.

There is an alternative with a new plan called 'Right Care, Right Person' involving the police and healthcare services working together. Let’s hope giving a deadline helps to concentrate the minds of the mental health services.

After almost 140 years of debate it is time to ensure that anyone with a serious mental health problem is not locked in a police cell.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice