Dr Peter Moore: GMC ensures today's doctors behave ethically - not an ancient Greek


Whenever a doctor misbehaves people shout: “What about the Hippocratic Oath?” This oath, it is believed, is taken by every new doctor and lays out basic medical ethics, first do no harm and so on. I confess, I have never sworn the Hippocratic Oath or an
Whenever a doctor misbehaves people shout: “What about the Hippocratic Oath?”
This oath, it is believed, is taken by every new doctor and lays out basic medical ethics, first do no harm and so on.
I confess, I have never sworn the Hippocratic Oath or any other oath. In the UK, doctors are kept in check by the General Medical Council (GMC).
There is no law which lays down medial qualifications. The law simply states that, to practice medicine, we have to be registered with the GMC.
It is the GMC that ensures we behave ethically, not an ancient Greek.
In the days of Hippocrates, around 400 BC, physicians could not do a great deal. Many of the doctor’s tricks were closer to stage conjurers than modern medicine and, just like today’s magic circle, doctors swore not to give away any of the secrets.
Any doctor trying to explain a treatment to a patient or the public is breaking the Hippocratic Oath. I’ve been doing it for years.
But the Hippocratic Oath is interesting. It begins: “I swear by Apollo the physician.” I’m not sure who Apollo was except the NASA Moon landings which can’t be right. It continues by asking all the Gods and Goddesses to be witnesses.
The first and longest section is to look after their teacher: “To hold him who taught me this art equally dear to me as my parents and to see his offspring as my equals.”
It also insists that I must teach his siblings without asking for a fee. I must teach my teachers' sons and my own sons the art of medicine but teach no other.
So, unless you are the son of a doctor, you can never become a doctor and if you’re a women, forget it. This oath only applies to men.
I was involved in teaching both medical students and trainee GPs but I do not remember any of them 'holding me as dear as their parents' but they were not all sons of doctors and I was paid so I committed multiple breaches of the oath.
There are some parts which might apply today. “I will not give a lethal drug to anyone if I am asked.” This rules out assisted dying. It also rules out any attempt at abortion.
As a physician they swear that they will not use a knife but leave surgery to the surgeons. It also emphasises the importance of confidentially. “Whatever I see or hear in the lives of my patients, whether in my professional practice or not, I will keep secret.”
Another section which still applies concerns home visits. “In whatever homes I go I will enter... for the benefit of the sick avoiding any voluntary act of impropriety of corruption.” I am not clear how any doctor could have an involuntary act of impropriety or corruption.
And the oath gives examples of impropriety including the seduction of women or men 'whether they are free or slaves'. At least it includes seducing women or men and so includes gay sex, which is very 21st century. Less 21st century is to include slaves. Fortunately, I was not aware of any slaves in the houses I visited although, sadly, this might not be the case everywhere.
It is reassuring to know that, even if I had met a slave, I would not be allowed to seduce them, man or woman.
Personally, I was never tempted to seduce anyone when on home visits. Not only would it be wrong and unethical but there is no way I had the time.
The Hippocratic Oath is important in the same way that the Wright brother’s first aeroplane is important. No one would go on their holidays in Wright’s plane today but they were the first. All modern aviation stems from their efforts.
The Hippocratic Oath tells us more about Ancient Greece than today’s medical ethics but it was the first attempt to lay down basic standards for physicians.
Apollo may not have been watching me but the GMC were.