Torquay United navigating the ultra unpredictable National League South


Torquay United head to Tonbridge on Saturday needing something to secure a play-off spot
A lifelong and ever-committed Gulls fan accosted your correspondent outside Plainmoor around 6pm on Saturday and, with a crestfallen look on his face, said: “Isn’t that us all over?”
He went on to mention how other results had kept on going in Torquay United’s favour, and how another big crowd had gathered to cheer them to what would have been a fifth successive victory.
And how, of course just when everything was set up for them, United had fluffed their lines.
Hemel Hempstead Town goalkeeper Michael Johnson had touched the ball only twice to real effect.
Once to pick the ball out of his own net after Deon Moore’s rousing 35th minute equaliser and once to hold a shot he could have thrown his cap on in the second half.
For the rest of the match too many United players – centre-forward Moore was one of the exceptions - had failed to get out of third gear.
Hemel had got in their proverbial faces and jolted them out of the stride that had lifted them up to third place in the National League South table.
And when the Tudors did win the ball, they were stronger, quicker and more decisive, led by the impressive Isiah Noel-Williams in midfield.
In their Play-Off Semi-Final defeat (0-1) to Boreham Wood last year, the Gulls had struggled to contain the pace and skill of attacking midfielder Abdul Abdulmalik.
Abdulmalik has been doing more of the same to National League defences this season and, surely, Noel-Williams could follow him, either with Hemel or someone else next season.
No doubt United manager Jimmy Ball said all the right things, before the match and at half-time. But not even a combination of Shankly, Clough and Ferguson could have turned the Gulls around on Saturday, although it would have been interesting to hear them try!
The NLS has been so relentlessly unpredictable all season that maybe we shouldn’t have been surprised, by what happened at Plainmoor or elsewhere.
All the top three teams lost.
Worthing, who have blown big leads in each of the last two seasons, must now beat in-form Ebbsfleet United at home this Saturday to make sure it doesn’t happen again.
Dorking Wanderers, who have taken only four points from their last seven games, can hardly be relishing a trip to Weston-super-Mare, who are a point behind them.
Hemel, who looked to be falling away only a couple of weeks ago, will fancy their chances big time at home to lowly Salisbury.
From having almost everything in their own hands, Torquay cannot afford to lose at mid-table Tonbridge Angels if they want to make the Play-Offs.
And suddenly United actually want second-placed Hornchurch to beat Maidenhead and knock out one of the sides that could gatecrash the post-season.
One thing is still in Torquay’s hands, and that’s to produce the sort of performance at Tonbridge that they failed to deliver against Hemel Hempstead.
Meanwhile, plenty of well qualified people have told us that the standard of the NLS is better, and the division more competitive, than ever. But is it?
If you judge it on hard figures, almost certainly not.
Even if Worthing win this weekend and clinch the title, they’ll still have five points less than either Truro City or the Gulls amassed 12 months ago.
And no one will earn 86 points, which was only good enough for Dorking to finish SIXTH last year.
With one game to go, look at the number of defeats suffered by the leading sides this season – Worthing 12, Hornchurch 11, Dorking 13, Hemel 13, Torquay 14.
Last season that same yardstick read: Truro 9, Torquay 7, Eastbourne 8, Worthing 10, Boreham Wood 12, Dorking 8.
The figures for wins are a bit tighter, but here goes: 2025/26 – Worthing 24, Hornchurch 23, Dorking 23, Hemel 23, Torquay 23; 2024/25 – Truro 26, Torquay 25, Eastbourne 25, Worthing 26, Boreham Wood 26, Dorking 24.
So, unpredictable from first to last, sure, but better?
Tonbridge here we come...
Just to recap, Saturday’s games that count are: Worthing (1) v Ebbsfleet (6), Hornchurch (2) v Maidenhead (8), Weston-super-Mare (7) v Dorking (3), Hemel Hempstead (4) v Salisbury, Tonbridge v Torquay (5) and Bath v Maidstone (9).