Torquay United manager has so many balls in air for team selection


United head for eighth friendly as manager Ball ponders team selection
Seven friendlies done, one still to go and, already, we should probably be congratulating Torquay United manager Jimmy Ball.
Why? Because nobody, but nobody, yet knows the 1st XI that Ball will send out to meet Horsham on the first day of the National League South season on August 8.
Well, Jimmy may well know. And he may have confided in his assistant Darren Way. But nobody else at Plainmoor – not staff, players, directors, nor any self-appointed ‘insiders’ – knows that first team of the campaign.
Of course, it has to do with the fact that Ball has assembled a new-look 23-strong roster since that 3 2 Play-Off Final defeat at Hornchurch on May 9.
Twenty-three into eleven doesn’t go, or even into a match-day squad of 18. Right through the squad, Ball has sought to create competition in every position, and he’s done it.
In goal, where Ball has two of his ten new signings, ex-Accrington, Shrewsbury and Wigan keeper Toby Savin, 25, may just have the edge over Zak Baker, 21, on the grounds of pure experience. But only just.
Ball also paid an undisclosed fee to bring right-back Dom Bernard, 29, from divisional rivals Weston super-Mare, so maybe he’s in front of Jordan Thomas or Harry Shield, the former Plymouth Argyle Academy youngster who has done well on trial. But from then on..?
There’s no more intriguing conundrum than the one at centre-back. For two years now United have been blessed with two of the best central defenders in the NL South in Jordan Dyer and Sam Dreyer.
There has been some transfer speculation surrounding Dreyer, but that’s now died down after the Gulls are believed to have rejected one offer out of hand. Dreyer has another year left on his contract and, even in the never-say-never world of football, he still looks like a settled and committed player.
Ball may have needed some cover at centre-back, but the recent arrival of Jake Wannell, 32, from the captaincy of Yeovil Town went beyond ‘cover’.
The centre-back ‘puzzle’ is, of course, extra-important, because it impacts on what ‘system’ Ball plans to use – a back-four or three in the middle with wing-backs.
Or is Ball preparing to adopt a much more flexible approach? One formation against certain opponents and another against others, depending on their threat? That would be bold.
At left-back there’s a full-on duel between two new young prospects in Tyler Hill and Kian Jenkins, and there looks precious little between them.
The three resident central midfielders are Munashe Sundire, Matt Worthington and Sonny Blu Lo Everton. Sundire has picked up where he left off in his impressive finish to last season. Worthington, the captain, and Lo-Everton, who proved last year that he can unlock NLS defences, are both obviously strong candidates to start. But here again, is Ball preparing to flex those tactical muscles in attack as well as defence?
In the second half of last Tuesday’s friendly against Plymouth, Ball took off Sundire, Worthington and Lo-Everton. He sent on Dan Hayfield and Matt Jay in the middle, plus Jordan Young and Dylan Morgan, with apparent orders for them to be wingers with the ball and midfielders without it – 4-2-4 or 4-4-2.
That’s hardly ground-breaking stuff, of course, but it was another hint of the way that the Gulls’ boss wants to have as many bullets in his magazine as possible.
Quick young right-winger Sean Robertson was also thrown into the mix after being left out of the previous couple of games to concentrate on a personalised strength and fitness programme.
Up front, the squad boasts the returning Deon Moore, Callum Morton, Isaac Westendorf, Louis Dennis and Sonny Fish.
Fish, who has had some more injury problems, did not feature in Ball’s squads at the end of last season, and he’s been linked with a move away.
Ball started with Moore, Westendorf and Morton against Plymouth, then changed things around to involve Dennis and Robertson for the last half-hour.
One consistent message has been that United should not be pushed around, physically or mentally, by anyone in 2026-2027.
If there’s one way to guarantee a Play-Off place at least, it’s keeping the number of defeats to single figures, as they did (7) when they finished on 89 points and lost the title to Truro City on goal difference two years ago.
Ball is determined to get back to that sort of resilience. But he’s also assembled good enough attacking players to go pretty direct to the muscular, pacy combination of Moore and Westendorf, as we saw in the first half against Plymouth, OR build up with crisp passing when the chance comes along.
In many ways, we shouldn’t get too hung up about that sort of ‘either or’. Good teams can nearly always do a bit of both.
In the wake of Saturday’s 5-0 win over Cardiff City’s Under-21s, the final friendly is at home to Exeter City this Friday (7.30pm). We may know a bit more after that game. But in the meantime Ball is keeping us all guessing about that 1st XI against Horsham...