The wing-back traditions at Plainmoor


The legend of Gurney and Gibbs
In the ninth minute on the first day of the 1997-98 season – it was also Macclesfield Town’s first-ever match in the Football League – Torquay United equalised at 1-1 in front of their own supporters at the open end of the Moss Rose Ground.
The view from the grandstand press box there is pretty good, but your correspondent still had to do a ‘double-take’ to be sure who had scored the goal.
What on earth was Andy Gurney, with No.2 on his back, doing beyond all the forwards to score from open play?
Gurney could have had a hat-trick that afternoon and, although Macclesfield won 2-1 in the end, we had seen the first glimpse of what became the tactical feature of a season which ended at Wembley in the Play-Off Final.
During that summer, manager Kevin Hodges had decided to play with a 3-5-2 formation and, more importantly, he’d signed the players to do it.
As well as Gurney, from Bristol Rovers, he brought in another bargain free transfer, Paul Gibbs from Colchester United, to play as the left ‘wing-back’.
Hodges already had two ultra-reliable central defenders in the formidable pair of Jon Gittens and Alex Watson, and he also added Jamie Robinson, an underrated left-footer from Carlisle United, as his third centre-back.
The Nos 2-3-4-5-6 of Gurney, Gibbs, Robinson, Gittens, Watson became the almost ever-present foundation on which that agonising promotion near-miss was founded.
Rodney Jack may have the star attraction up front, and rightly so for his trickery and blazing pace, but it was that overlapping duo of Gurney and Gibbs who gave opposing managers just as many sleepless nights.
The proof of the pudding is in the 20 goals they scored between them, even if half-a-dozen came from Gibbs penalties.
Football pundits have become increasingly obsessed with tactics and ‘systems’ over the years. No Match Of The Day ‘analysis’ would be complete without those ever-changing shaded shapes, whether they make any real sense or not.
And, of course and Thank Goodness, there never has been one ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ way to play the game. Long may that continue.
But one of the best routes to goal is and always has been to cross the ball from out wide, and the further forward you do it from the better.
For that, you need out-and-out wingers. Or a pair of fit, able and inexhaustible wing-backs.
Over the last 25 years or so Torquay, and loads of other teams for that matter, have used the 3-5-2 many times, often shoe-horning full-backs or wingers into the wing-back positions.
But it’s nearly always been a pale imitation of the way Gurney and Gibbs did it.
They were relentless and, whenever they sought an understandable moment’s rest, they always had Gittens, Watson and Robinson to order them up and back again. You didn’t say ‘No’ to those boys!
They weren’t the first, for Cyril Knowles had done something similar ten years before.
He brought centre-back Phil Lloyd with him in the summer of 1987, stuck him alongside David Cole and John Impey at the back and used the attack-minded Jim McNichol and Tom Kelly as raiding wing-backs.
McNichol scored eleven goals that season and, although he didn’t hit the net, Kelly supplied plenty of crosses for others to do it.
United reached the Play-Off Final that year too.
There’s an old and very true saying in football that you should always fit formations to players, not the other way around.
The Gulls supporters who saw Gurney (he was sold to Reading for £100,000) and Gibbs, and McNichol and Kelly before them, have always known what a proper ‘3-5-2’ looks like.
Footnote: At the end of January this year, several members of that 1997-98 side, including Gibbs who travelled down from his home in Great Yarmouth, gathered in Bristol to celebrate Gurney’s 50th birthday. Happy days!