The Promotion Myth: Why spending big often ends in failure

Influencer KSI brings the cash to Dagenham & Redbridgeplaceholder image
Influencer KSI brings the cash to Dagenham & Redbridge | Garry Bowden/PPAUK

Money does not buy success in the National League South

You might think, when something doesn’t work and often keeps on not working, that the obvious answer is to do something different.

But that would be sensible, and football, especially professional football, is very seldom sensible.

Yes, money can talk, of course it can.

Back in 2007, a new board paid for just-relegated Torquay United to buy themselves a promotion team.

It still took them two years, and even more money, to do it.

But the recent history of the National League South is hardly a recommendation for ‘splashing the cash’.

Yeovil Town’s 2023-2024 budget must have been decent, but the list of champions or Play-Off winners includes clubs like Truro City, Braintree Town and, last season, Worthing and Hornchurch.

None of those were the division’s big spenders.

In fact, Chelmsford City, Dagenham & Redbridge and Maidstone United all carried wage-bills around the top of the list, and none of them even made the Play-Offs.

Three of the leading scorers were Brad Dolaghan, who was largely unknown outside West Ham Under-21s and Worthing, followed by Louis Britton (Weston-super-Mare) and Wiktor Makowski (Slough/Worthing), both part-timers.

Britton, who plenty of clubs had given up on, is still a painter and decorator in his day job.

The season before, two of the top four marksmen, Tyler Harvey (Truro) and Cody Cooke (Torquay), were also part-timers.

Yet the list of clubs who are prepared to throw ever-increasing amounts of money at the hope of winning promotion to the National League shows no signs of evaporating.

Torquay United are, of course, a bit different at this level.

Any NLS club which can pull in 4,000 gates at the merest sign of success carries with it that ever-demanding ‘expectation’ word, and the Plainmoor board has to act accordingly.

But at Dagenham, Chelmsford and Dorking Wanderers, where they crack open the champagne when more than 2,000 turn up, you sometimes wonder what’s in it for them.

Gulls co-chairman Michael Westcott, who fears that endless over-spending is a recipe for disaster, tried to sell the idea of a salary-cap at the recent National League AGM.

The silence has been thunderous since that meeting, a bit like news on 3UP promotion with the EFL.

Having gone so close twice – goal-difference in 2025, PO Final losers last time – United and owners the Bryn Consortium have given manager Jimmy Ball a ‘contenders’ budget to do the job this season.

But United are still not the top spenders.

Dagenham, freshly backed by influencer KSI, have allowed new manager Lee Allinson from Hemel Hempstead to sign 13 players at the last count.

And you don’t persuade guys like new captain Harry Beautyman to move from Woking for three pints of lager and a packet of crisps.

Chelmsford, who also have a new boss in ex-Swindon, FGR and Yeovil manager Mark Cooper, have sanctioned another rebuild under him.

City already have the man who may be the highest paid player in the division in striker Lyle Taylor, even at 36.

At Dorking, Marc White has hauled in new investors to try and keep his Wanderers on an upward trajectory.

Ebbsfleet, who have wracked up eye-watering losses over the last few years, continue to pay well.

Maidstone, who failed to turn their lucrative run to the 2024 FA Cup Fifth Round into promotion, are a bit more circumspect these days, but they remain one of the more ambitious clubs.

And around the M25 ‘corridor’ there are always teams who have a summer ‘flutter’ - and then pull their midwinter horns in if the gamble fails and gates drop back into three figures.

In 2026-2027 don’t be surprised if, as usual, a relative ‘outsider’ helps to set the pace, or even stays there for a while.

The key to eventual success won’t be simply the fattest chequebook, but a decent one allied, as ever, to the most astute recruitment.

Let’s hope that Ball, more than any of his rival managers, has got that combination right...

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice