Jimmy Ball faces promotion balancing act as Torquay United seek promotion formula

Torquay United manager Jimmy Ball. Pic from PPAUKplaceholder image
Torquay United manager Jimmy Ball. Pic from PPAUK | Frankie OKeeffe/PPAUK

Torquay United boss Jimmy Ball navigating the summer transfer window.

Torquay United fans may need to ask themselves a simple question this summer: ‘If promotion is so important, are you prepared to trade some of last season’s goals and entertainment for more clean-sheets and consistency?’

That’s the poser that manager Jimmy Ball is tackling as he tries to turn the Gulls from near-missers into winners.

The facts are there for all to see.

In 2024-2025, with a post-administration budget under Paul Wotton, United lost the National League South title on goal-difference to Truro City after amassing 89 points.

The key ‘stats’ were only seven defeats and 42 goals conceded in 46 matches, before they lost in the Play-Off Semi-Finals to Boreham Wood.

United won 25 matches, but scored ‘only’ 73 goals, and everyone then asked manager Paul Wotton to rebuild his midfield and create a more open and attacking side.

He did just that.

Result? The Gulls last season were second only to champions Worthing in games-won (24) and goals-scored (87), 50 of them at a well entertained Plainmoor.

But those seven defeats in 2024-2025 doubled to 14 and the goals-against went up from 42 to 62. United finished third before dispatching Dorking Wanderers 4-2 in the PO Semi. But, true to form, leading twice in the Final at Hornchurch wasn’t enough to save them from a numbing 3-2 loss.

Ball has already hinted that his top priority during this close-season is adding more substance over style.

United cannot afford too many more of those exasperating defeats at Chippenham, Eastbourne, Horsham, Chesham etc if they are to go up next year.

As usual, several of their rivals are already pushing the proverbial boat out to try and hit the jackpot.

But before anyone starts to worry that they might be stealing a march on United, it’s worth remembering what happened last season.

Chelmsford, Dagenham and Maidstone were among the biggest spenders, and none of them even made the Play-Offs.

Chelmsford splashed serious cash, or one of their major sponsors did, to sign players like experienced striker Lyle Taylor from League Two Colchester United.

They’re at it again, in support of another new manager, Mark Cooper, whose NLS title win with Yeovil Town in 2024 helped to get him the job.

One of their key signings may prove to be a 76-year-old ‘director of football’ who’s something of a legend in non-League circles.

Former Maidstone, Dagenham, Barnet and Luton manager John Still has a record six promotions at these levels to his credit, but he’s nearly as well known for his scouting acumen and contacts.

Sure enough, Chelmsford have hardly stopped signing players since last season finished.

Twelve months ago, all the talk was about Dagenham & Redbridge.

They bought Kidderminster Harriers’ top scorer Ashley Hemmings, signed ex-England centre-forward Andy Carroll and several others, which prompted the bookies to make them favourites to win the division.

Under new ownership, including investment from influencer KSI, and with a new manager of their own in Lee Allinson from Hemel Hempstead, the Daggers are at it again .

They’ve already tempted midfielder Harry Beautyman, 34, away from the captaincy at National League Woking and snapped up veteran goalkeeper Nathan Ashmore (Boreham Wood), Kane Crichlow (Sutton), Archie Tamplin (Chelmsford), Kyrmani Thomas (Brentwood) and Antony Papadopoulos (Crawley).

Carroll is now player-coach under Allinson.

But money doesn’t guarantee success in the NL South, and it’s very easy to pay over the odds.

Nearly every promotion contender over the last few seasons has had a serious ‘blip’ at some stage, but the teams that overcome it are the ones with as much character and durability as pure talent or reputation.

Nobody suffered more injuries last season than Dorking Wanderers, and nobody signed more players to try and stay in the title race.

But the Wanderers missed out in the end, as they had done in 2025, and now owner/manager Marc White is wheeling and dealing again.

He’s already snapped up Dover Athletic’s leading scorer George Nikaj, Aldershot Town forward Josh Barrett, goalkeeper Glenn Morris, 42, from Gillingham and defender Charlie Sayers (Hampton & Richmond).

But the ‘Cocks’ have also lost several of their most effective players from last season – Charlie Carter, goalkeeper Harrison Foulkes, defenders Tony Craig and Jordan Norville-Williams, as well as loanees Harry Sidwell, Kai Enslin, Liam Vincent and Sam Pearson, all regulars over the second half of the campaign.

White retains all his energy and ambition, and he will doubtless have a strong-looking squad by the time next season kicks off, but he’s tackling a fair old rebuild at Meadowbank.

As ever, there are always likely to be those ‘cheeky upstarts’, relatively unfancied sides with modest budgets, but still eager to upset the pecking order.

Torquay came unstuck against several of them last season, including Horsham and AFC Totton. Totton, under Ball, and Horsham were both freshly promoted.

The new boys now are Billericay Town, back in the NLS after a three-year absence, and ‘debutants’ Walton & Hersham, who won the Southern League by eight points from Play-Off winners Farnham Town, and Folkestone Invicta.

No matter how hard you work at your recruitment and how much you spend, it’s not and never will be an exact science, as even the billionaires of the Premier League rediscover to their cost every year.

There’s no instruction manual.

And, although lots of clubs like to do their business early to gee up those season-ticket sales, plenty of in-demand players keep their options open until at least the middle of June, often later.

In the wake of left-back Jay Foulston’s departure at the weekend, and the arrivals of young goalie Zak Baker and striker Callum Morton, Ball is still waiting on offers to centre-forwards Cody Cooke and Deon Moore.

He may not be chasing too many ‘marquee’ newcomers, but more ‘steady eddies’ to cut down on those defeats and goals-against.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice