Jake Robinson and the game with no points

Jake Robinson. Pic from PPAUKplaceholder image
Jake Robinson. Pic from PPAUK

A bizarre story of ineligible players at Plainmoor

We have just passed the 13-year anniversary of a story that ranks as one of the strangest in Torquay United history: two ineligible players, deducted points and a long march down the touchline.

It all began on a cold night in early February 2011 when United Director Bill Phillips walked to the dugout after just a few minutes of a League Two clash between Torquay and Hereford at Plainmoor.

Jake Robinson, freshly signed on loan from Shrewsbury, had just given the Gulls an early lead: the problem was that Robinson wasn’t freshly signed, and Phillips was informing manager Paul Buckle that Jake’s paperwork had not been rubber-stamped by the Football League.

United played the rest of the game knowing the result didn’t matter, as the fielding of an ineligible player would mean an inevitable points deduction and fine, which duly arrived a few weeks later.

Even more bizarrely, however, Hereford, who went on to win the game 3-1, also had an ineligible player in their team, so they had three points deducted.

It was, in reality, a game that cost both teams points and pounds, although United still managed to reach the play-off final at Old Trafford, losing 1-0 to Stevenage.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice