Hesitancy and nerves ultimate cost Torquay United on the big day

Jay Foulston on the floor at Hornchurch. Pic from PPAUKplaceholder image
Jay Foulston on the floor at Hornchurch. Pic from PPAUK

Reflections on a disappointing result at Hornchurch to end Torquay United promotion dreams

From Whitechapel, where the sleek, silver Elizabeth Line meets the old green District, there are 16 stops on the way out to Upminster Bridge, where the Hornchurch Stadium, with its athletics track, throwing cages and long jump pit, hides behind the trees of a quiet, leafy housing estate.

It takes about 40 minutes, but when you’re on your way to a Play-Off Final, optimism makes the journey speed by.

Opposite the station, it may have taken ten minutes to get a pint at the Windmill, but the pub did a roaring trade, its garden filled up with noisy fans decked in yellow and blue, and the mood gave few concerns to the police drafted in to keep an eye on things.

It was the same inside the ground where, with hardly a yellow line in sight, 3,000 somehow crammed in.

Yes, ‘Hornchurch, May 2026’ will go down as one those ‘I Was There’ days. But, as a long, tense and increasingly frantic afternoon unfolded, not for the reasons we all hoped.

It was no Southend or Woking, or even Hemel Hempstead 12 months before, when United had won 4-1 but lost promotion on goal-difference.

They say that goals change games, but they didn’t for United on Saturday.

Twice they rocked Hornchurch and took the lead, in the sixth minute and the 78th, as Deon Moore moved into his muscular overdrive and left the home defence in his imperious wake.

What a shift he put in.

But each time it wasn’t United, with the breeze behind them in the first half, who stamped their authority on the game.

They almost seemed to hesitate, to wonder whether to keep going forward, against opponents who couldn’t match them when they got the ball down and passed it, or gave Moore another chance to turn their defence and chase a long ball.

Take a bow, Munashe Sundire.

Charlie Carter for Dorking Wanderers and Angelo Balanta for Hornchurch had led their clubs’ runs to the Play-Offs, but they hardly got a kick worth the mention against United’s fit-again midfield marker.

Neither really did Josh Rees, whose ‘ghosting’ runs and cool finishing had won so many games for the Urchins.

But, crucially, the hosts’ experienced full-backs Josh Hare and Sam Ling did keep two of United’s most dangerous players, Jordan Young on the right and Dylan Morgan on the left, quiet.

Neither was allowed to deliver their trademark cut-in runs and shots. And neither went on the outside often enough to deliver the crosses that might have set up Moore for a second goal.

Sonny Blu Lo-Everton did test Arthur Nasta from 25 yards, but the doubts in too many United minds helped Hornchurch recover from Moore’s early goal – and when you score can be almost as important as if you do.

On the stroke of half-time the Gulls were caught on the counter, Seb Stacey dashed out a moment too late, took Charlie Pegrum’s legs and Dominic Poleon sent Stacey the wrong way from the penalty.

The second half was a nervy stalemate, sprinkled with substitutions, until 12 minutes from time.

Then, from inside his own half, wide on the left with few apparent options, Callum Dolan produced a moment of magic – a turn and raking crossfield pass that set Moore away on the right.

Two good touches, split by another powerful run, and a precision 20-yard shot just inside the left-hand post...eight goals in six games for the big man, 2-1 up, National League here we come?

The stadium, and no doubt Plainmoor and that PO Watch Party too, rang to the roars of the Gulls faithful.

And again it was snatched away. United could not hold on.

In the third minute of stoppage-time Darren McQueen, an old-fashioned winger, did go on the outside, did cross and fellow sub Henry Hearn was there to bundle the ball over the line.

Quite how Nasta kept out Dan Hayfield’s header, from a Dolan cross, in the first half of extra time, not even he still knows. He just made himself ‘big’ and hoped for the best.

Both teams looked out on their feet – Moore had to be taken off, his cramp was so bad – and penalties looked a certainty.

But Hornchurch had a final attack or two left in them.

One more high ball, one more challenge, one more loose ball and that last low cross-shot by Ling that bounced across the goalmouth and in off the far post...117mins 2-3.

Was there a push on Louis Dennis? Possibly.

Hornchurch had protested that Moore did something similar before scoring 101 minutes before.

These things tend to even themselves out.

Of all people, it had been Ling, the son of former Gulls manager Martin Ling, who had settled it, with his first goal for more than two years.

No Carlisle, Southend, Scunthorpe or Yeovil next season. Hello Folkestone Invicta, Walton & Hersham, Farnham Town...oh, and Truro City again.

Those 16 stops back to Whitechapel took a lot longer than they had done at lunchtime.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice