Gary Johnson: Is the Academy system working, especially for English players?

placeholder image

By Gary Johnson, manager of Torquay United It was reported the other day that, over the last few weekends, only 32 per cent of players in the Premier League were English. There was one Saturday recently when it was as low as 28 per cent apparently. And

By Gary Johnson, manager of Torquay United

It was reported the other day that, over the last few weekends, only 32 per cent of players in the Premier League were English.

There was one Saturday recently when it was as low as 28 per cent apparently. And in the last January transfer 'window' 80 per cent of the players signed by Premier League clubs were from overseas.

We've just started an international 'break', and there's bound to be a worry that having such a small number of 'our' lads playing in our top league must be bad for the England team.

I've always said that the Premier League is now a 'World' League, because that's exactly what it is.

But I also think that you can look at the 'home v foreign' thing two ways.

One, it surely means that, playing with better players from different cultures should improve our English players. The quality of the PL has almost certainly gone up because the best in the world are playing in it.

Or two, it could affect the England team because there's less for Gareth Southgate to choose from.

About five years ago Premier League clubs either couldn't or wouldn't buy English players because they had priced themselves out of the market. The feeling was that foreign players were not only cheaper, but also as good, if not better.

The finances that have come into the PL, from sources like Sky, have doubled or even trebled over the last five years, so now the top players and their agents are demanding much bigger fees.

It also brings in the subject of how clubs produce their own players, and whether the Academy system is really working, especially for English players.

It's something that I've watched from the 'inside', as it were, for a long time.

First, a really good player will develop naturally anyway.

There are some you have to work harder with, and you have to remember that, in this day and age, they're growing up in a different culture to when I was looking after one of the very first Academies at Watford.

Academy kids at top clubs today are undoubtedly looked after very well, which isn't a bad thing, because everyone is so frightened of losing the best ones and having to buy them instead.

Some lads do come through early but a hell of a lot drop away because they're not ready when it comes to the time of signing a first pro contract.

Not all of them are like our Southampton loanee Nico Lawrence, who's only 19 but already has the physicality and mentality of a man.

But those other lads can drop down, grow into men and then come back. So nobody should be disappointed about being released from a top club Academy.

Of course, the big clubs have the finances to run under-21 and also under-23 teams.

They realise that young players often need more time to grow up these days, so they're virtually still part of their youth systems even at 21.

I do wonder whether extending it to under-23 might be going just a bit too far, because by then a player should be benefitting from working with all those top level lads we were talking about - wherever they come from.

Meanwhile, it was good to hear that 400 fans were at Plainmoor to see our Women's team beat Sherborne Ladies (2-1) on Sunday.

That must have been a big boost for Steve Elswood's team, who I believe need a win and a draw from their last two games to win promotion. All the best to them.

It's Dagenham and Redbridge at Plainmoor this Saturday, and another very important game in our fight to stay in the National League.

Our fans were good as ever against Wealdstone in our last home game, and 173 of them made it all the way to Gateshead last Saturday. Thank you to them all - we never take them for granted.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice