FA Cup diminishing as a money-spinner for smaller clubs

placeholder image

When the name of Derby County followed Torquay United out of the FA Cup First Round draw, the possibility of the Gulls making some serious money out of the competition at last seemed odds-on. Even manager Gary Johnson said that a draw at Plainmoor would b

When the name of Derby County followed Torquay United out of the FA Cup First Round draw, the possibility of the Gulls making some serious money out of the competition at last seemed odds-on. Even manager Gary Johnson said that a draw at Plainmoor would be as good as a win.

The Gulls did hold the Rams in that first tie, coming from 2-0 down to draw 2-2, with live TV coverage extending the audience well beyond TQ1.

More live TV for the replay seemed to be a bonus.

But one of the unexpected facts to emerge from the first-ever games between National League Torquay and Derby, one of the biggest clubs outside the Championship, is that the first match grossed more than the replay. A lot more.

Even primary school maths confirm that 4,269 fans at an average of £18 a time is worth more than 7,203 at £8.  We're talking a little over £75,000 against £57,000.

Don't forget that considerable expenses have to come out of those receipts before they're split between the clubs.

For instance, United were instructed to double their normal stewarding numbers for the home game.

Yes, live broadcast fees, worth another £80,000 for the two games, did sugar the pill, but the underlying message comes over loud and clear.

The FA Cup ain't wot it used to be!

For years now, the biggest Premier League clubs, claiming the extra pressures of burgeoning UEFA commitments, have been emasculating the 'world's greatest cup competition'.

By playing almost reserve sides, until the very latest rounds at least, they have diminished the FA Cup's standing, and the Carabao (League) Cup too, and given fans ever fewer reasons for watching them.

When Derby, cheered on by 5,000 supporters, met Liverpool in Carabao at Anfield the other night, they drew 0-0 before penalties, but with the Reds' Reserves/U23s.

But it's most worrying for the rest of us in the FA Cup.

Even slashing prices to £10/£5, Derby managed to attract only 6,370 of their own fans to the Torquay replay (plus 833 Gulls fans).

The big boys have already sucked the glory out of the Cup. Now it's even harder for the 'minnows' to make a few precious bob out of it.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice