Departure of Gulls quartet highlights how youth development is stacked against smaller clubs

placeholder image

Amid all the speculation following Torquay United manager Gary Johnson's retained list, the presence of four names in the 'released' section may have gone under the radar. They were 'homegrown' quartet Olaf Koszela, Jack Winsor, Lewis Brooks and Alex Moy

Amid all the speculation following Torquay United manager Gary Johnson's retained list, the presence of four names in the 'released' section may have gone under the radar.

They were 'homegrown' quartet Olaf Koszela, Jack Winsor, Lewis Brooks and Alex Moyse, and their departures beg the obvious question - where does it leave the Gulls' youth 'Academy'?

The first thing to say is that their release, and the previous departures of other former graduates like Louie Slough, Owen Price, JJ Evans and Andy Collings, is no reflection on coaches Ryan Dickson and his predecessor Chris Todd.

Dickson has only been in the job, which he combines with a full-time post at Paignton's South Devon College, for a year, and United have not, so far, announced whether they are giving first-year pro contracts to any of his current under-18 squad.placeholder image
Dickson has only been in the job, which he combines with a full-time post at Paignton's South Devon College, for a year, and United have not, so far, announced whether they are giving first-year pro contracts to any of his current under-18 squad.

The whole business of bringing young players through to senior level is stacked against smaller clubs. Especially at Torquay, who receive none of the Premier League funding which helps Exeter City and Plymouth Argyle in the EFL.

Their under-18 side also plays in the SW Counties Youth League, below the level where the Grecians and Pilgrims teenagers are tested each week.

And on top of that is the ridiculous situation where clubs like Torquay can nurture a youngster all the way from under-nine level, and get him to the point of offering him a professional contract, only for a bigger club to 'steal' him away with a deal of their own.

That's what happened when Wigan Athletic signed United's under-18 goalkeeper Matt Wonnacott last summer. There was nothing to stop the Latics doing it, without the Gulls receiving a penny in 'compensation'.

That scenario has been repeated at lower division clubs all over the country in recent years.

All calls are down to judgement in the end and United, like many other clubs, try and develop their youngest pros by sending them out on loan, while keeping an eye on them in their own training sessions.

That hasn't been enough to earn Koszela, Brooks, Winsor or Moyes an extension this year.placeholder image
That hasn't been enough to earn Koszela, Brooks, Winsor or Moyes an extension this year.

Exeter, perhaps out of necessity at the time, committed to a long-term youth policy to help their survival 20 years ago under the Supporters' Trust which still runs the club.

It has proved a winner, in sales and results, and successive managers have been encouraged to 'blood' their best prospects at first-team level and accept it if it didn't quite work. It often has.

United, whose original 'training scheme' was such a huge success - Lee Sharpe, Darren Moore, Paul Hall, Duane Darby, current Head Of Youth Robbie Herrera, Matthew Gregg, Tony Bedeau, Garry Monk, Mike Williamson etc - have paid the price for a far more erratic policy under successive regimes which saw several South Devon talents go elsewhere.

Today, there's nothing wrong with the basic structure of United's youth programme - their under-16 side has just won its Junior Premier League and there's plenty of great work going on in the various age groups.

But there is one clear problem.

Without a reserve or under-21 side, neither of which looks affordable or practical, the gap between the under-18s and the first team appears too big for those 'rookie' pros to bridge quickly enough.

The easy answer, of course, would be to unearth a truly outstanding local talent and hang onto him for a while. But then, the Mark Lorams of this world don't come along every year.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice