Balancing budgets and expectations at Plainmoor


Learning from the past for future financial stability at Torquay United
In the summer of 2007 just-relegated Torquay United, with a new board generously backed by lottery winners Paul and Thea Bristow, went out and bought themselves a football team (writes Dave Thomas).
They had one of the biggest budgets in the Conference (National League), and chief executive Colin Lee and manager Paul Buckle spent it.
You’ll remember the names that rolled into Plainmoor – Chris Hargreaves, Tim Sills, Chris Todd, Lee Phillips, Kevin Nicholson, Elliot Benyon, Danny Stevens, Chris Zebroski on loan.
And when they reckoned they needed mid-season reinforcements, there was more money available – Steve Adams, Roscoe D’Sane, Kaid Mohamed et al swelled the squad.
United won 34 league and cup games during that season of revival. It still wasn’t enough to take them up.
Out came the cheque book again in 2008.
In came Nicky Wroe from York City (£12,000), experienced duo Wayne Carlisle and Lee Hodges from Exeter City and Plymouth Argyle and others.
And on that memorable day at Wembley the following May, the job was done – United 2 Cambridge 0, back in the Football League.
Money talked. Well, at least it certainly helped. As it continued to do as United nearly made it to League One in 2011.
But that level of boardroom support couldn’t carry on for ever.
Only three years after the League Two Play-Off Final at Old Trafford, and as Bristow’s widow Thea decided that enough was enough, United were relegated again.
The Gulls have looked at the EFL from the outside ever since.
They’re funny things, budgets.
No manager in his right mind would turn down a big one. But when you’ve got plenty of money, every rival club and every agent knows it and up goes the ‘ante’.
There’s also the added pressure that comes with having more money than the rest.
What would be happening at Boreham Wood now if last season’s Play-Off Semi-Final at Plainmoor had gone Torquay’s way?
It’s easy to assume – and many fans understandably do - that United, with comfortably the largest gates in the division, will have the biggest budget in the NL South next season.
They won’t.
At least half-a-dozen other clubs, with help from their owners and backers, will reportedly be heavier spenders. Or at least on a par.
So there’s every reason to believe that the NLS will be even harder to get out of than it was last time around.
It’s worth remembering that wages in the Home Counties, especially inside the M25, are higher than those outside, which always pushes up prices there.
Torquay’s geographical situation is also a key factor, and not just in a negative way.
It increases the importance of pursuing players who want to buy into the club and the area, rather than paying lip-service to it.
We’ve seen a few of those over the years.
By all accounts, Munashe Sundire and Louis Dennis are up for the whole English Riviera buzz. And Callum Dolan obviously wants more of what he tasted on loan two years ago.
United’s Bryn Consortium board may have a few bob, but not the sort of largesse which the Bristows once bestowed.
And while manager Paul Wotton will obviously want as much money as possible, he’s a man who has qualities like character, professionalism and durability among his boxes to tick, along with pure talent.
Nobody would argue with the current board’s desire, now driven by new CEO Mark Thomas, to raise the club’s non-matchday revenues to a point where annual losses are more supportable than in the past.
But there’s a balance to be struck and, as ever, that’s the difficult bit.
The Bryn Consortium, full of successful and committed people, are definitely not the first board to try and walk that tightrope, while everyone else judges them purely on what happens on the pitch.
Good luck to them. And to Wotton, as he tries to spread that budget as astutely as possible.
After all, Truro City and Torquay United finished first and second last season, separated only by goal-difference, and neither of their budgets were in the top half-dozen.