When everyday language becomes a diagnosis


The growing use of psychological jargon risks trivialising serious mental health conditions
Whenever I look on social media, there are click-baits trying to get my attention with homely psychology. “Test your IQ”. “Are you autistic?”. “Are you a narcissist?”. Once clicked on, they can grab our data. This plays on the latest fashion of “therapy speak”. It is now common to throw around psychological terms rather than using simple English.
The problem is that psychology is rather more complex. IQ is misunderstood. It measures whatever it is that IQ tests measure. Intelligence may be a part of it, but not the whole story. It was once described as testing eyesight by asking someone to play a Beethoven Piano Sonata with the music score getting smaller. Eyesight would affect the result but, more importantly, so would whether you could play the piano.
What is more worrying is the way that psychological jargon has crept into everyday speech. “She’s a bit OCD because she likes to keep her bedroom tidy”. This is unfair on people who are disabled by real obsessive compulsive disorder. I knew of one genuine patient suffering from OCD who, when said “touch wood”, stopped the car and ran across a field to touch a tree. Even a piece of wood was not enough. This disabling condition is more than wanting the bedroom tidy.
Depression, medically, is more than just being unhappy. If someone has been bereaved, lost their job, or has a marriage problem, being unhappy is normal. It might be pathological if they were inappropriately happy. Serious depressive illness is devastating. Everything, even the good things in life, looks dreadful. Sleep is poor, with waking up in the early hours. Ultimately, it can lead to suicide. To say “I’m a bit depressed after Torquay United lost” is not true. I am unhappy but do not have clinical depression.
Falling out with someone or not liking their attitude is normal. It does not mean that other person is “toxic”.
Equally, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a serious mental health problem after major trauma. In the First World War it was called “shell shock”. There were several undiagnosed cases I saw from people who had suffered severe stress in the Second World War. It leads to horrific flashbacks. A lecture about sexual offences does not lead to PTSD, although a victim of a serious sexual offence might suffer PTSD.
Even neurodiversity creates problems. Recently, Professor Dame Uta Frith of University College London, who has spent a lifetime studying autism, expressed concern that the diagnosis is so overused that it has become meaningless. When she started in 1966, it applied to a very small number of extremely disturbed young children. In the 1960s, autism led to severe problems with speech and language, IQ, and social skills. The number of severe cases has not changed, but the number of people diagnosed with autism has dramatically increased.
Although the diagnostic criteria have not changed, the interpretation has. Professor Frith herself proposed the idea that the severe cases are one end of a spectrum, now called autistic spectrum disorder. Today, at the mild end, it has almost become fashionable to claim to have autistic traits. There is also a risk that people with genuine severe autism can be overlooked. Many people with mild autistic traits may have a problem, but should it have a different label?
Autism is a real problem but, as with all these other psychological problems, it needs a full assessment by a professional. There are clear diagnostic criteria.
The problem is that the assessment for these psychological problems takes time. There are no blood tests or scans which would help. If every time someone claimed a psychological diagnosis they underwent a thorough assessment by an NHS professional, waiting lists would be so long that, by the time they were seen, they would need a geriatrician.
The danger with throwing around therapy speak is that normal human behaviour can be turned into an illness. People are all different. Being a bit eccentric is not a problem and does not need a label. Some of the best brains in history were looked upon as a bit odd in their day.