Waiting on Westminster as Torbay's future hangs in the balance


As Devon awaits the Government's decision on local government reorganisation, Cllr Steve Darling reflects on what the changes could mean for Torbay, why he believes closer ties with neighbouring areas deserve consideration, and his latest appearance on the BBC's Politics Show.
Doubtless there are folk in the Town Hall waiting for the phone to ring (or the email to ping) so we can all be put out of our misery & learn the government's thoughts regarding local government reorganisation in Devon, including Torbay. We were told the decision would be revealed by mid July at the latest, so Town Halls can start preparing for local elections next May. The most likely scenario is we will be electing councillors to serve on a "shadow authority" at the same time as existing councillors serve for an extra year in tandem with this new shadow authority which will have a say on the bigger budget issues & major policy decisions.
So it could be an interesting eleven months if the new & the old don't see eye to eye.The decision might well be announced this week which would be appropriate as the Great & the Good of local government gather for the annual Local Government Association Conference. Or perhaps the Secretary of State will keep quiet until after the Conference for fear of causing upset in Bournemouth. We have been advised matters will still progress regardless of the resignation of the Prime Minister & a likely new broom in Westminster. It seems there is consensus on this topic at least: the days of two tier local government are over & single tier unitary councils, like Torbay & Plymouth are the way to go.At the outset, the Secretary of State invited proposals for new unitary councils of 500,000 or more residents, which is why Torbay & Plymouth were added to the mix. Both councils are much smaller & Torbay is something of a minnow with fewer than 140,000 residents, one of the smallest in the land.Since then the message has altered somewhat; in those areas where new council boundaries have been finalised there are several with a population of 300,000 or less, with the Isle of Wight allowed to continue on its existing boundaries, rather than combined with a part of Hampshire, even though its population is almost exactly the same as Torbay (& like Torbay a retirement/holiday area facing very great demographic challenges as its population ages).So perhaps the way forward for those who would like us to stay as we are (which is Torbay's official position) is to start digging a wide trench around the Bay, cutting us off completely from our neighbours & then Red Funnel could provide a ferry service to/from Newton Abbot in place of the Number 12.My own thoughts have been a bit different to this "official" position & I would like to see Torbay working as one with neighbouring areas. The current boundary is very tightly drawn & it's clear to me many services are shared across South Devon, such as the various hospitals, the South Devon College, transport links, schools & more. Such tightly drawn boundaries have separated Torbay from some of its more affluent "hinterland" creating significant challenges for our people services, both children's & adults. Newton Abbot, Kingskerswell, Totnes & Marldon might not be a land of milk & honey, but they don't endure the deep-rooted social issues & multiple deprivation of central Torquay & Paignton. A better balanced population & ideally slightly younger overall might lead to a more viable council in the long run.All this & more might be something to discuss when I go down to BBC Plymouth on Friday & participate in the Politics Show which is broadcast on Sunday morning. It always amuses me when I get a call a day or so before the recording, with the charming lady who puts the programme together sounding ever so slightly frantic & explaining they have been "let down" (again!) hoping to get some shadow cabinet member into the studio perhaps. Names are NEVER mentioned.
Of course, Yours Truly is only too happy to oblige, Fridays for some reason are generally quiet & dear friends will say "off you go" & not at all upset they will be without my company for a coffee or a walk or whatever we might have pencilled in. There's always next week.On this occasion I was asked a full ten days ahead which I take as something of a compliment & it doesn't seem they are desperate at all. I always travel down on the train, walk to the studios & reflect on what I plan to say. It goes around & around in my head for most of the journey. On the way home I reflect on what I WISH I HAD SAID & again it goes around & around. When the camera is actually on & the discussion is live it's a different thing altogether: a struggle to actually get the words out & I can be sat there thinking this isn't making much sense. Of course the host Martyn Oates is absolutely charming & sits there with a slightly bemused expression as though he has heard it all before, most likely because he has.Anyhow, it's very kind of them to keep asking me down. They know I will always turn up (although once I was so late due to big problems with the rail service I thought they might have liked me to do the travel report instead) & even if I am quite a way down the guest list, at least I am still on it.By Friday we might have a clearer idea of how the Labour Party leadership is shaping up & whether anyone else is likely to throw their hat into the ring & challenge the King of the North, Andy Burnham. When I wrote about this some weeks back I suggested a female candidate might come forward. It seems remarkable to me, my lot are on our fourth female leader but the Labour Party, who you would imagine would be pushing the equality agenda, seem unlikely to get their first.Watching Question Time the other day I thought Dame Emily Thornberry was absolutely magnificent, quite regal in her exchanges with Zia Yusuf representing Reform. Surely someone could run around Westminster & secure the necessary 81 nominations to avoid a coronation?It does seem a very odd state of affairs with over 400 MPs the Labour Party is putting its faith in someone who hasn't even been around in Westminster for nine years & who has lost two leadership contests already: against Ed Milliband in 2010 & Jeremy Corbyn in 2015.It's a funny old world, you might say.