Two Michaels, one question: Ball or Bublé?


From West End showstoppers to smooth swing classics, Michael Ball and Michael Bublé offer audiences very different experiences
Ball or Bublé, who’s the best? That’s the question.
Now, I must confess I have never seen Michael Bublé live, and I do not expect his next British tour will bring him to Torbay. But I did see Michael Ball last week at the Princess Theatre and, as the reviews confirmed, he was brilliant. His style and personality were warm as he told us about the songs, like he was speaking personally to each member of the audience. It is much like the presenters at Torbay Hospital talking to patients via the airwaves, making sure that they feel we are having a chat with them. There was huge emotion in what Ball sang and said, but if you want silky Canadian charm, it’s the other Michael, the crooner, you want.
Now, I am not going to choose. I have found that you are on rocky ground when you put two icons up against one another, and I am not going to fall into that trap. But, of course, there is no reason why you cannot pick one over the other. Now Ball has a whole host of theatrical credits in the locker, Les Misérables, Phantom and Hairspray, to name just three. Add to that two Olivier Awards and a voice built for storytelling, he is a clear contender. Clearly the British heavyweight champion of musical theatre.
In the other corner is the real big hitter and arguably the World Champion, a global icon famous for his swing-era classics and probably more so for his Christmas albums. He is smooth and just oozes charm; sprinkle in Grammy-winning records, huge worldwide tours and it’s difficult to put your money on the other horse in this race. Of course, they are different in many ways but, put simply, one hails from the West End, one from the Rat Pack tradition.
Of course, your preference depends on what you value most, Ball’s big vocal style, full of theatrical power. Or Bublé’s silky and controlled phrasing, reminiscent of the late Dean Martin. Both can tell a story and sell a show with drama and charm and, with awards on both sides of the seesaw, it is a difficult choice for sure. Ball is a British national treasure, Bublé a household name all around the world, especially every December.
Strangely, the two Michaels actually performed together, with a surprise duet of “Bring Him Home” in 2025. The song from the musical Les Misérables saw Ball, who first captivated audiences as the young romantic Marius in the original 1985 London cast of Les Mis, and Bublé perform together on the stage of the Sondheim Theatre. Apparently, as Ball launched into the opening lines, a familiar silhouette appeared stage right. Michael Bublé took the harmony line, the performance was spellbinding.
In a post-show interview, Ball said, “To return to this role meant everything to me. But to share it with someone I admire as much as Michael Bublé? That was pure joy.” Bublé added, “This show, this song, it’s a prayer. Singing it beside Michael — the man who made it what it is — that’s something I’ll never forget.” Clearly the two titans have a huge amount of mutual respect for one another.
So who’s best? Well, if you want pure power, drama and the joy of musical theatre, surely it is Michael Ball. However, if you prefer smooth, romantic, jazz-pop charm then you will probably lean towards Michael Bublé. I am still sitting on the fence, I like them both. If you were to base your decision on record sales then Michael Bublé wins by a huge margin. He is a global chart act and Ball is a UK theatre-driven recording artist. In terms of theatrical hit shows, it is Michael Ball who wins decisively. He is a West End titan with iconic roles across multiple blockbuster musicals.
Obviously, they are very different and comparison is difficult and you might prefer home-grown talent to someone from over the pond. In any event, good luck choosing your favourite.