Torbay Hospital, social care and the politics of health


As campaigners fight to protect local services, attention must also turn to the wider challenges facing the NHS and social care
It is somewhat ironic the reform of social care in the UK has now got to the top of the agenda, with our new Prime Minister talking about the benefits of integration of health & social care, just as our partners at Torbay Hospital have pulled the plug on our local model of integrated health & social care here in Torbay. Something which is regarded nationally as a model of good practice is coming to an end next April, just months before Baroness Casey publishes her report, which might well suggest following the Torbay model.
Andy Burnham has gone as far as to say you need to sort social care if you want to save the health service. In simple terms, having effective social care in place at the very least reduces pressures on hospitals, providing support for residents to live independently in their own homes, with someone keeping an eye on older people in particular to ensure minor issues can be treated before they escalate into more serious conditions. Once folk are in hospital, then you need packages of care in place to allow timely discharges & to make sure patients have the best chance of recovery.
It was somewhat off key for Councillor Steve Darling, who is also a Member of Parliament, to make such a thing of this Section 75 arrangement coming to an end in Torbay on the "watch" of the current Conservative Town Hall administration when he spoke at the most recent Council meeting. The facts are we negotiated in good faith with local NHS colleagues in the run up to the renewal of the Section 75 agreement in April 2025, just last year, which was supposed to last until 2030; the decision by health colleagues to break this agreement so quickly is disappointing to say the least & very much against our wishes.
Accepting Steve Darling can't be in two places at once, I would suggest in his shoes he might be better off spending his time in Westminster building relationships with the Labour government and banging the drum for Torbay. If he could arrange a visit by the Secretary of State, never mind the Prime Minister, to see a fully integrated system of health & social care in action before it's broken up, then I would be more than happy to give my little Skoda a clean & polish before picking up any VIPs from Torquay Station & giving them the full tour. Just say when?
It's also rather sad this is all going on as banners appear & the local Heart Campaign changes gear with the new rallying cry "Save Torbay Hospital". Indeed, I was a couple of minutes late for last week's Wellswood Community Partnership when Susie Colley was on the agenda to bring us up to date with all her campaigning, as I was watching the local BBC News, which carried a report of maternity services coming to an end at North Devon Hospital. It seems Torbay isn't the only place with problems.
The fundamental problem in North Devon isn't a lack of cash but rather the difficulty in recruiting staff, in particular appropriately qualified doctors to oversee maternity services. This all rather chimes with what I was told many moons ago when I first heard of conversations regarding the future of Torbay Hospital: there were huge issues with the recruitment & retention of staff. The staff then were significantly older than is usual, so substantial numbers were bound to retire in the years to come.
We really need a grown up conversation about all this. In an ideal world we would have a forum like we used to (a "Local Strategic Partnership"), where matters can be reasonably discussed, slightly removed from the political point scoring & with debate which is less shouty than at a mass public meeting.
If the fundamental problem is the recruitment & retention of staff, then claiming Torbay Hospital is about to be closed down or at the very least downgraded into a "Cottage Hospital" (I am not sure such a designation officially exists) is far from helpful. If I was a bright young person (if only) about to embark upon my medical career, then I am not sure I would be rushing to send off my CV to anywhere with such a question over its future.
My guess is it's a bit of an uphill struggle to recruit bright young people to further their careers in a place like Torbay in any case. It might be scenic, but there are issues with housing; there is perhaps less of a "buzz" compared with Exeter up the road & other places with a much younger population. The political culture often seems a bit bonkers to me, with a very old-fashioned view as to what the future might look like & endless upset over things which, in the great scheme of things, are minor. By contrast, the really big issues generally get swept under the carpet. Only in Torbay, as you might say.
The biggest challenge by far is created by a rapidly ageing population & as our population grows more slowly than other urban areas, then our working age population actually begins to contract. This is made worse by rather higher rates of working age residents who are not "economically active" (a wonderful phrase), also far fewer residents with a degree or equivalent qualifications compared with other places, making it almost impossible to fill some positions.
We all want to experience safe & effective health care. Whether everything can continue to be provided on our doorstep in the same way as before remains to be seen. It seems reasonable to me that different health trusts work together. The Royal Devon & Exeter Trust has provided dialysis treatment in South Devon for years & since 2012 from a satellite unit at Edginswell.
We must be a genuinely welcoming place, especially in the context that nearly thirty percent of staff who work in the NHS are from a minority ethnic background. All the wretched flag waving & ghastly rhetoric might come back to bite us if folk decide, entirely reasonably, an old-fashioned seaside/retirement place isn't for them.
We also need to take pressure off the NHS by making strides in public health & ensuring we have good social care in place, even if we have to go back to delivering it from the Town Hall.
I can only admire professional colleagues at Torbay Council who are picking up the pieces as the Integrated Care Organisation comes to an end at the same time as we progress local government reorganisation & new boundaries.
There's never a dull moment.
Best wishes,
Nick Bye