Torbay Council’s full meetings: more heat than light

Nick Byeplaceholder image
Nick Bye | Torbay Council

Nick Bye reflects on some of Torbay Council’s more fractious meetings, the strange arguments that can erupt over apparently straightforward decisions, and why residents ultimately care more about results than political point-scoring

Hold the front page, Mr Editor! I have some important news: the world will keep spinning whether or not Torbay Council holds a "full" meeting on September 17th. Indeed, judging by what has gone on at a number of Council meetings over the last few years, I might add things are more likely to spin smoothly if we are given the night off.

This is not a criticism of my fellow Councillors & certainly not the officers (definitely not the officers who have to sit through these sessions). Rather, there is something about these "full" council meetings which brings out the worst in everyone & it's hard to see how they add value. Instead of being the shop window for Torbay Council, they are at times an embarrassment. The poor Chief Executive & Monitoring Officer sit on the platform with the Mayor, wearing bemused expressions & all too often must intervene to restore order.

Older members (& readers) might recall Joyce Grenfell & her marvellous monologues, especially the nursery school teacher with her gentle admonition, "George, don't do that".

You get the picture.

The last Council on July 23rd was a classic. There was more than an hour of unpleasant debate concerning how we might spend a £174,000 surplus from the 2025/26 financial year. The obvious point to make is many councils up & down the land facing bankruptcy would be absolutely delighted to have a surplus to discuss & spend. The second point is the debate was on a cross party amendment, which presumably had been agreed by more senior figures than Yours Truly, intended to ensure as far as possible everyone was content.

But no! All sorts of things were said, wish lists perhaps & speeches made, points scored which had little to do with the matter in hand.

At the end of it all, guess what? There was a UNANIMOUS vote to spend the money as outlined in the cross party amendment on some more street cleaning & graffiti removal. Indeed, the awful graffiti above Rock Walk should be gone by now. Hurray!

So why did it take more than an hour of unpleasant exchanges to get to a vote on something everyone was agreed upon?

If we can't even manage a reasonable debate on a subject when all are agreed, then of course things are very much worse when opinions are divided. Because the number of councillors on either side (administration & opposition) are closely balanced, then the position of Mayor becomes hotly contested as the Mayor has a casting vote.

In reality, the Mayor has rarely used their casting vote, perhaps just a handful of times in 3 years, as agreement is often reached (see above) & so far the administration has generally achieved a solid turnout, especially on budget setting issues when some opposition councillors have been conspicuous by their absence for reasons we can only guess.

Each year the Council chooses a "Mayor Elect" in the early Spring, then elects the Mayor at the subsequent Annual Council in May. Instead of being a pleasant civic occasion, these events have often turned into a bloodbath, all the worse when family & friends are in attendance. It's worse than embarrassing & I have done my best to calm things on three occasions when proposing Hazel Foster for high office. Things have been said which absolutely should never have been said.

I remember my late grandmother advising, "if you can't say anything nice about someone, then it's better to say nothing at all".

Of course, she wisely refrained from entering local politics.

At the July meeting, we also had the absolute joy of a discussion on taking the draft Local Plan to a "Regulation 19" consultation. A huge amount of work has gone into this new Local Plan for Torbay, which sets out, amongst many things, where houses can & can't be built over the next twenty years or so.

You couldn't have a more important document, & remember this debate in July was to allow a consultation before further revision & then inspection by a government-appointed inspector in due course.

Bizarrely, a faction of Liberal Democrat Councillors decided to oppose this, even though it would scupper the whole process & we would end up without an effective local plan for several years, resulting in less protection for precious green spaces. Voting this down would have sent out entirely the wrong signal.

Fortunately, two Independent Councillors voted with the administration (the two others were absent!); the draft minutes show three Liberal Democrat Councillors, the best of the bunch you might say, abstained, so the vote was easily carried.

Unfortunately, the numbers didn't stack up in June 2024 when opposition councillors possibly "mistakenly" or perhaps mischievously voted against a routine annual motion to agree the officer scheme of delegation, thereby freezing the day-to-day operations of Torbay Council & necessitating the Chief Executive (who deserves some kind of medal) to obtain King's Counsel advice at goodness knows what cost. This scheme of delegation was absolutely no different to the one voted through for the four years of the Liberal Democrat/Independent administration.

Despite polite & delicate enquiries, no one has ever given me a reason as to why they voted the way they did. Surely accountability should apply to an opposition as well as an administration?

Having got all that off my chest, let's finish off with something more positive & absolutely Torbay at its best. I was absolutely delighted to see the new children's play facilities in place & being used at Stoodley Knowle, Wellswood, on Friday morning when Madam Mayor & fellow Ward Councillor Hazel Foster declared the playpark "open".

Very many thanks to all involved in this project, especially our SWISCO officers & the children at Ilsham Primary School who contributed their ideas. It was great to see the smiling faces & all part of our ambition to be a UNICEF Child Friendly Place. Several more improved play parks are on their way.

Meetings have their place, but most people just want to see things get done.

Best wishes,

Nick Bye

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice