The NHS data revolution: from John Snow to digital health


How connected patient records could transform healthcare, improve treatment and unlock powerful new research opportunities
Not all medical breakthroughs happen in a lab. In 1854, Dr John Snow confronted a major cholera outbreak in Soho, London. At the time, there were two main theories: one held that cholera was spread by “miasma”, or foul air, a view supported by Florence Nightingale and others; the other, championed by Dr Snow, was that it came from polluted water. Snow plotted the cholera cases on a map and noticed they clustered around the Broad Street water pump. The local council removed the pump handle, and the epidemic subsided. I am not sure a council would be so decisive today.
We now know that cholera is caused by a microorganism in water, but this discovery, like many others, came not from laboratory work but from studying whole populations.
Today, John Snow could have made the same observation with a quick computer search. By computerising the NHS, we have created an extraordinary research tool.
Almost the entire UK population is registered with a GP, amounting to 63.6 million people. In theory, we could examine, for example, how many people take statins to lower their cholesterol and see whether any patterns emerge. Nowhere else in the world has such a comprehensive database. In countries with insurance-based health services, people are registered with different companies, some of which may not accept high-risk patients, so there are no complete national figures.
The problem was that NHS computer systems could not communicate with one another.
When I worked as a GP in Torbay Hospital’s A&E department, I was employed not by the hospital but by the out-of-hours service, Devon Doctors. A patient might say, “I was here yesterday,” and I would have to explain that they had then been an A&E patient, so their records were not on my computer.
“OK, I saw my GP last week.”
Sorry—the GP practice used a different system too.
“You’ll have to start again with your medical history.”
Patients, quite rightly, thought this was absurd.
Hospitals could not access GP notes, and GPs had to wait for letters from hospitals to learn the results of outpatient appointments or operations.
When on call some years ago, a family came to see me who were on holiday. Clearly, the young child was very ill, short of breath and a poor colour. When I listened to her heart, there was a loud murmur. She was in heart failure and probably had an issue with one of the heart valves.
Giving bad news is never easy, especially when it involved the health of a young child.
“Has she ever had problems with her health before?”
“No, she’s always been fine.”
I rang the hospital but, after I had spoken to the paediatrician, the child’s mother added, “She’s under Great Ormond Street because of the heart, but I’m sure you know that from her notes.”
I didn’t.
There is now a proposed £1 billion digitalisation plan for the NHS. It has two aims: to create a single record for every patient and to analyse overall statistics.
The good news is that Devon is ahead of the field. Torbay and South Devon is only the second trust to move to Epic, an electronic patient record system. GPs and mental health services can link into it. We are moving towards national single patient records. Once this is fully rolled out, anyone registered with an NHS GP who falls ill anywhere in the country will be able to have their records accessed by the local GP or hospital.
For wider analysis, the NHS Federated Data Platform (FDP) connects data from different hospitals and GP practices to help staff plan more efficiently.
Of course, confidentiality is paramount. Anyone from a computer company who leaked personal details could end up in prison. When data is analysed at population level, it is difficult to identify individuals. Research into the 77,000 people with diabetes in Devon, for example, would be unlikely to reveal whether Mr Jones of Arcadia Avenue, Torquay, was diabetic.
Any major change carries risks, but the benefits will be enormous. Better communication would greatly improve NHS care. The research potential is remarkable. We could quickly discover, for example, whether certain health problems are specific to the South West.
One problem in the UK is that we can become so bogged down in rules and regulations that nothing gets done. This is an opportunity to revolutionise our health service and create a world-beating research tool. Dr Snow would be amazed.