Should doctors leave personal beliefs at the hospital door?


A Torbay GP reflects on changing expectations of professionalism, from tongue studs to political badges, and asks where the line should be drawn between personal expression and patient trust.
A medical student turned up in our practice with a tongue stud. Was this appropriate for a
potential doctor? Was I just an old dinosaur? Should I accept that life has moved on and get
used to it?
When I was a student back in the 70s we had to have short hair and wear a collar and tie. It
was explained to us that, as a doctor, we would be dealing with some difficult emotional and
personal problems. People had to trust us as if their lives depended on it, which they might.
We had to look the part.
I rang the student’s tutor at the university. I was right. He pointed out that in any medical
consultation the focus of attention must always be on the patient not the doctor. Anything that
takes away that focus is unhelpful.
I explained this to our student who understood and had the stud removed.
I was reminded of this incident when I read that there is a new ruling that health professionals
in the NHS should not wear political badges at work. I was shocked. I cannot imagine any of
us wearing political badges in hospital when I was a junior doctor. The powerful consultants,
ward sisters and matrons would have commented in ways which might not be acceptable to
today’s generation.
The government adviser, Lord Mann, was asked to look at antisemitism in the NHS and he
found that Jewish doctors were being ostracised and Jewish patients reluctant to seek help.
This included Jewish women who were sometimes reluctant to have their baby in an NHS
hospital. Antisemitism is racism and racism has no place in medicine. I would go further and
suggest that a racist has no place working as a doctor.
Lord Mann’s advice was to ban all political badges from NHS staff at work. He also
proposed that no NHS staff should wear NHS clothes such as scrubs on political
demonstrations. Anyone wearing NHS uniform of any type is representing the NHS.
Last year my old training hospital trust, Bart NHS Trust in East London reviewed the rules on
dress codes after there were complaints from patients about staff wearing free Palestine
badges and football shirts at work. One elderly Jewish patient at Barts was deeply upset to
see staff wearing pro-Palestinian clothing and badges. He was right to complain. When I was
a student at Barts I would have been thrown off the ward for not wearing a tie or having long
hair. I suspect I would have been thrown out of the medical school if I was wearing openly
political badges. I did not wear scrubs but a white coat which made me look more like an ice
cream seller than a political agitator.
Two doctors and a nurse took legal action against Barts for banning political clothing and
badges and lost. The lawyers commented that it was “not appropriate for staff members at a
hospital to display their political views”.
Throughout my career I was careful to avoid expressing any moral, religious or political view
to patients. If I ever appeared to openly support a political party or movement it would
immediately damage the doctor patient relationship for any patient who did not agree. If they
believed my judgement was so poor in this area how could they trust my medical judgement?
The situation is even worse if racial prejudice is involved.
The pro-Palestinian lobby may have passionate views about Gaza but that does not give them
the right to openly express these views on the ward.
When I worked in prisons I ran surgeries in the VPU (Vulnerable Prisoners’ Unit) where
prisoners were kept if they were at risk in the main prison. I never asked why they were there
although it was likely to be horrific crimes such as child abuse. My role as a doctor was to
care for people and not make judgements.
The General Medical Council which regulates all doctors states “you must not express your
personal beliefs (including political, religious and moral beliefs) to patients in ways that
exploit their vulnerability or could reasonably cause then distress.”. Wearing political badges
or Free Palestine clothes is expressing a political view and is likely to cause some Jewish
patients distress. Not only should staff not wear political badges and clothes in hospitals but
doctors who openly ignore these rules should be reported to the GMC. This is far more
serious than a tongue stud.