Risk, benefit and the missing conversation

Weighing risks against benefits placeholder image
Weighing risks against benefits | Elena Mozhvilo

Why patients need to hear not only the dangers of treatment, but also the consequences of refusing it

A friend of mine with heart disease was due to have a stent, a small tube in the artery around the heart to help the circulation. The cardiologist explained all the risks involved, which sounded horrific.

“So, what is the risk if I don’t have it done?” he asked.

“If you don’t have it done, you will have a major heart attack soon and probably die.”

This was over twenty years ago, and he is still fit and well. It did make me realise listing all the dangers of a drug or other medical procedure does not give patients the whole picture.

In Adam Kay’s book about his time as a junior doctor in gynaecology, This Is Going to Hurt, some patients asked, “What’s the worst that could happen?” Would anyone ask that before getting on a plane or getting in a car? The worst that could happen is that you could die, but it is very, very unlikely.

Whenever doctors recommend a new medication, operation or other procedure, they have to balance risk against benefit. We all do this every day. Before crossing the road, we look to see whether there is any traffic coming. If there is a bus a few metres away, the risk is higher than our desire to get to the other side. If it is all clear, the risk is low and we cross.

The risk is never zero. There is always a chance that someone will come along at high speed or there is a cyclist we did not spot but, on balance, the risk is very low.

One of the problems today is that health professionals have to run through every possible risk before a procedure but do not have to explain the risks of not having anything done.

Although potential risks and side effects should be explained to patients, we do not always emphasise the risks of not having the procedure. People might sue if they were not told about a particular risk but are unlikely to sue if they suffer from not having the procedure.

Is anyone going to take legal advice using the argument, “You listed the dangers if I had the treatment, but you never explained what might happen if I refused.” Is anyone going to sue when their child suffers from measles after refusing the MMR vaccine? Can they argue that no one explained the risk from measles is much higher than the risk of autism, a risk based on discredited research by a doctor who was struck off the medical register?

The leaflets given to patients with their medication can be scary. One patient came to me having read about a side effect from the drug. I had never heard of this problem and, more importantly, it was not listed in either the British National Formulary or the data sheet. These provide independent information about any drug doctors might prescribe.

I wrote to the pharmaceutical company. In their reply, they explained that this side effect had been noted in a very small number of cases worldwide. International medical experts reviewed all the evidence independently and concluded that these “side effects” were not caused by the drug. It was a tiny number and they were merely a coincidence.

As a result, it was decided that this should not be included in the warnings for patients. Unfortunately, the company were so worried about being sued they listed it on their leaflet included with every prescription.

I can see why they were worried. If another patient suffered this side effect, even if it was nothing to do with the drug, they could be sued. “You knew about this risk but kept it hidden.”

Before any hospital procedure, people have to sit down and have the possible risks explained. Can I suggest that any patient asks another question: “What is the risk if I do not have it done?”

The answer is probably “much higher”.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice