‘Lines drawn on a map’ - MP criticises Devon’s council shake-up

Caroline Voaden MPplaceholder image
Caroline Voaden MP | Caroline Voaden

Caroline Voaden outlines concerns over the future of rural Devon and the impact on local representation

So, finally, in the last hours of Keir Starmer’s premiership, the government has staggered to a decision on local government organisation, with the Secretary of State Steve Reed coming to parliament last week to confirm the landscape of Devon and Torbay will be redefined in a way that only benefits Labour.

To do this on the last day of term, when many MPs had already headed back to their constituencies, was outrageous, leaving little to no time to engage with Ministers about what they were forcing onto the country.

This, combined with the absolute illogicality of the government’s decision, leaves me in little doubt that the carve-up of Devon is politically motivated. Driven by a desire to prioritise the growth of Plymouth and Exeter at the expense of the rest of Devon.

It’s quite complicated, so please bear with me…

Teignbridge will be sliced up, with a chunk of it merging into Torbay. This new unitary authority will also take in rural parishes from Kingswear to Stoke Gabriel and Berry Pomeroy. Even though Kingswear and Dartmouth operate as a fairly integrated town, connected by a ferry, they will now be handled by separate councils.

And because the eastern edge of Totnes is in Berry Pomeroy, it looks like this will mean Totnes will be divided between this big new authority, and what can only be described as ‘rural rump Devon’, which will stretch from Barnstaple to Salcombe. An authority that will have no city anchor, no economic powerhouse and will have to deliver services across a hundred miles of dispersed, rural communities.

These are just a few examples showing how hollow the government’s words on community representation were. It appears lines were simply drawn on a map in London without any care about what that looks like on the ground.

Six proposals were submitted by Torbay, Plymouth, Devon, Exeter and the District Councils. None could agree on the best option, but many versions allowed Plymouth to grow its boundaries, while leaving some sense of cohesion and potential for the rest of the county.

Instead, we have a decision based entirely on growing Plymouth and Exeter, building houses, and enabling economic growth. It confirms a view that I have held since the 2024 election: Labour not only doesn’t understand rural areas, it doesn’t care about them either.

In the letter we received from the Secretary of State there was scant mention of this ‘rump’ rural Devon authority – it was treated as an afterthought which doesn’t neatly fit the Labour metropolitan view – they clearly thought they’d just skip over it and concentrate on the shiny new vision for Devon’s two cities and an urban(ish) council joining up Torbay and Newton Abbot.

I’ve already said I’m not sure how Manchesterism will translate to Devon – if this is a preview then I’m not sure I want to see the main event.

To put it plainly, it’s fairly clear that there is a whole swathe of Devon that will struggle to reach its potential under this model, and a load more places that feel no connection to their new council.

For Brixham it will mean the town being part of a much larger authority area than at present, so the Town Council will have a much more important role to play in giving Brixham a voice. I will give it all the support it needs to shape a future for Brixham in this new authority.

I know councillors and officers at Torbay Council will work hard to make the transition as smooth as possible and to set up the new structures needed to make this work.

There won’t be any change in the services you receive from the Council now, and they will keep residents informed of changes as they are made. If you have any questions or would like to contact me about these changes, you can always email my office at [email protected]

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice