In Search of the Missing Male Voices


Why are so few men joining mixed community choirs? In this week's column, the author reflects on the challenge of recruiting male singers, explores the rise of men's singing groups and sea shanty crews, and explains why singing has become such an important part of his life and wellbeing.
So where can I find men who sing? This has become a bit of a mission for me, as it seems
difficult to find men who will come and join the mixed choirs with which I sing. I have
spoken to many people about this, including choir leaders and choir members. One thought
that emerged was that men feel vulnerable when sing with women, but more secure when
singing with other men. Could that be the case? Men don’t want to look silly, or be open to
criticism?
Of course, the growth of shanty crews has provided a musical home for many male singers,
which is not that surprising given the relatively straightforward arrangements that
characterise many sea shanties. And let’s face it, shanties are fun and very appealing to
audiences, with lots of rousing choruses and audience participation.
Could it be that early experiences have something to do with it? Primary school choirs, very
sadly, often consist entirely of girls. So are the boys off playing football or doing other
“manly “pursuits? Is the relative lack of male teachers in primary schools something to do
with it? I don’t know…I merely pose the question.
There are some notable men’s choirs around: the Spooky Men’s Chorale, the AK47s for
example. But the situation locally with mixed community choirs is very unbalanced. On
occasion, I have found myself singing as the only bass in a choir of 50 odd. And that, let me
tell you, is a very interesting musical experience.
So anyway, a few days ago I set off for the charming little Wiltshire village of Pewsey, in
Wiltshire, in the company of Nic and Paul, with whom I sing in Wren Music’s men’s
group…which is known, somewhat predictably, as Mensing. We meet every month in
Okehampton to learn predominantly folk songs. Once a year we have a residential weekend
when we meet up to learn new techniques and new songs, and to learn a bit more about
each other. So we are looking for a new focus for our annual weekend together, and came
across a Festival called Bloke Fest. This is, as its name suggests, is entirely for blokes who
like singing or think they might.
“It’s about having a great time and getting g away from the cares of the normal world, our
day to day existence and singing songs together: talk with a man and he’ll become your
friend. Sing with a man, and he’ll become your brother.”
So Paul, Nic and I set off for Pewsey early one Saturday morning from Exeter St David’s
Station. Pewsey is not far from Stonehenge and it’s quite a long drive. We were welcomed
by one of the organisers and invited to join a workshop to get a flavour of how Bloke Fest
works. The Festival takes place in a filed basically full of blokes and tents. The blokes all
seemed very friendly and the workshop was fun: blokes learning a three part harmony song,
led by the son of Paul Sartin who some of you may know as a wonderful folk musician who
sadly died not long ago. So we then had a coffee and a chat and set off for home.
I don’t yet know what the outcome of this venture will be. We will have to discuss the idea
with the rest of Mensing. What I have learned through singing since I retired, at a time when
the subject of men’s health, and particularly mental health, is a hot topic, is that I get a huge
buzz from singing: with other men or in a mixed choir. Learning new songs keeps me at least
relatively mentally agile. But there is something very special about a mixed community choir.
The mix of soprano, alto, tenor and basses is especially satisfying.
So I shall keep singing and hope to persuade other men to join me.