From the Union Jack to the Stars and Stripes: Are today’s superpowers repeating the mistakes of the past?


As the United States prepares to mark 250 years since its Declaration of Independence, this column reflects on Britain’s own imperial past, national pride and whether today’s America is following a path once familiar to the British Empire.
I have a copy of “The Tiger Tim’s Annual” from the 1930s. On one page there is a riddle. “Why is the sun like the Union Jack?”. The answer, I am sure you have all guessed is “because no power on earth can bring it down”. Today it is still a joke but not in the way the authors of the Tiger Tim annual meant. The Union Jack has been taken down all around the world from the former British Empire but, as far as I know, the sun is still in the sky even if it is behind rain clouds.
As the Americans celebrate 250 years since the Declaration of Independence would this riddle work in MAGA-land (make America Great Again)? The riddle “Why is the sun like the “Stars and Stripes” might work. When Great Britian really did rule the waves from the nineteenth century up until the Second World War our ancestors may have had a similar mindset to today’s patriotic Americans. In Land of Hope and Glory we still sing “wider still and wider” but not many of us still want to expand into other countries. But would the line work in Trump’s USA? Wider still and wider to take over Greenland, Canada and even Cuba. They would love the line “God made thee mighty” when British politicians “don’t do God.”
In Victorian Britain there was the idea that the whole world would love to be British. We considered ourselves the most successful country in the world. Like the Americans today our aim was to “civilise” the rest of the world. And civilise meant to make them all British. We did not respect other cultures or understand that they are valuable. I have a slightly embarrassing tablecloth which has been handed down through the family. It is called, “The civilisation of Fiji”. On one side are the “savages”, the next side shows Boadicea arriving. We then see the “natives” starting to dress like the Brits. The final side shows the natives all dressed as Victorian Gentlemen and Ladies bowing to each other. The British Empire today receives deserved criticism but, unlike some other empires the aim was often to convert the locals to the British way of life. When the Americans spread west they did not try to convert the natives but pushed them off the land. In Argentina the natives were slaughtered by the Spanish.
Although I am not sure that everyone wanted to be British, we were very a successful country. In the same way that the USA leads the world in tech with Google, Meta, Amazon and numerous other companies, we led the world with the first steam trains and the industrial revolution. Britain was building more ships than any other country. Even in my childhood anything steel often had “made in Sheffield” embossed on it. We tried to export our laws and culture around the world. It was our ancestors who designed the built the “railroads” in America and India. The Sydney Harbour bridge was built in Middlesbrough by British engineers and shipped to Australia. Even in the early tech days we laid the first undersea cables. Before we criticise the USA are they in the same position that we were over a hundred years ago? Donald Trump and Elon Musk have both tried to interfere in UK politics without really understanding our culture. Without meaning any harm, they believe that theirs is the best system and so everyone else should follow suit. Just like the Victorian British they believe their civilisation is superior. When Elon Musk suggested that the centre of Birmingham has been taken over by Muslims making it dangerous for white people, did we have a similar patronising attitude to other countries in the past? Foreign natives are always fighting each other and violent.
The USA is a new country. There is an old, probably apocryphal story about a British academic talking to an American. “What are you studying?” “American history”. “What do you do in the afternoons?”
We should celebrate the USA’s 250 years. They even believe that this is a long time. Without wishing to sound patronising should we look upon the USA as we might one of our successful teenage children? Their behaviour might be embarrassing for us grown-ups but remember, we were the same when we were young.