Fordingbridge case raises questions over sentencing, accountability and justice system gaps


A doctor reflects on a murder confession, the complexities of court verdicts, and a controversial Fordingbridge sentencing involving teenage sexual offences, arguing that justice can only be understood when the full context and history of a case are considered.
I was once asked by the police to examine a man’s his minor injuries. I gave my usual advice.
“Although I am an independent doctor, I will have to repeat anything you say if ordered by
the Court”. I got the reply, “I don’t care. I’ve just murdered my wife”.
In court I repeated his line and so I was surprised when I heard that there would have to be a
retrial. The jury could not agree a verdict.
When I looked at the whole case it was not as bizarre as it seemed. It was agreed he had
killed his wife. The difficult decision was whether it was murder or manslaughter. Did he
deliberately kill her or was it accidental? The defence argued that when I saw him he was so
distressed that he did not understand the significance of his comment. Not many lay people
understand the subtle difference between murder and manslaughter. I only had one small
piece of a large, complicated jigsaw.
This taught me to be careful criticising a court’s verdict or sentence unless I have sat through
the whole trial and heard all the evidence.
And so I was cautious when I read the strange sentence given to the three teenagers in
Fordingbridge. Two committed rapes and a third filmed them. Rather than being locked up
they were given youth rehabilitation orders. For the victims it is a life sentence of traumatic
memories and flashbacks. There is an appeal on the grounds that this sentence was too
lenient and so it is unlikely this sentence will stand.
What made this even more bizarre is that this appalling crime was not a one off. Although
previous allegations cannot be raised in court before a verdict, a judge is entitled to take
previous behaviour into account when sentencing. One of the boys had a history of sexual
offences from the age of ten. In 2022 one boy was reported to have pinned a girl against a
wall and told her to take her clothes off. Two weeks before the first rape they had attacked
two girls. Ten days before one of the boys was reported to have held a 14-year-old girl
around the neck while the other one put his hand up her skirt. Although reported to the police
none of these cases resulted in police action. This meant that the barrister for the prosecution
could tell the judge before sentencing there were no previous convictions, reprimand or
cautions against any of the boys. Because the police had taken no action earlier was the court
unaware of their history? If they had been cautioned would it have been different?
The judge also commented that one had ADHD and a very low IQ. When I was trained to
assess whether people were fit to interview or appear in court I was told that any diagnosis is
irrelevant. We cannot say that because someone had been diagnosed with a particular mental
health condition they cannot be interviewed or charged. The question is not what is the
diagnosis but do they have capacity? Do they understand?
We can go back to 1843 when Daniel M’Naghten tried to shoot the Prime Minster, Robert
Peel and inadvertently killed Edward Drummond. The usual punishment was the death
penalty but it was clear that M’Naghten was, to use the term used at the time, a lunatic. As a
result he was found not guilty. This led to a public outcry, including from Queen Victoria.
A House of Lords committee then developed the “M’Naghten rules. For someone to be guilty
of a crime they have to understand “the nature and quality of the act” and understand that it
was wrong. If someone believed they were being attacked by aliens when they hit out they
did not understand it was wrong. These were very different times, but the basic ideas still
stand.
These rapes were preplanned and filmed. Even though the boys were only children it is
inconceivable that they were unaware of their actions. ADHD and low IQ is irrelevant if he
understood his actions and knew it was wrong.
I do not like to criticise a sentence without knowing the whole story but is this a case of the
judge not knowing the whole story?