Don Mills: The Gull with the golden left foot

Plainmoorplaceholder image
Plainmoor | Derek Harper / Geograph (CC BY-SA 2.0)

More than three decades after his death, Don Mills remains one of the most celebrated figures in Torquay United’s history

Voted the greatest “Gull” of all time in a poll run by the Herald Express newspaper in 1998 commemorating the Centenary of the Football League, Don Mills topped the poll when named the man with the “golden left foot”, having scored a record number of goals that season.

Don (his birth name) Mills was born on August 17, 1926, in Bramley, Rotherham, South Yorkshire. Having played football from an early age, his formal career commenced after joining Queens Park Rangers (QPR) in the 3rd Division in 1945. Three years later he was on loan in Devon as inside forward at Torquay United Football Club in his No. 10 shirt for a year.

Interestingly, Don was spotted by “football scouts” who were forever travelling the county seeking out future football stars. Don was soon reported by regional journalists in sports columns, stating he was “a very good player”. Some even started to keep a summary of goals scored, and one journalist said “he had contributed enormously to QPR’s Third Division Championship match that QPR eventually won that year”.

Don finally appeared in eighty-six games for QPR during 1946-1951, scoring nine goals for the team. Yet, for some odd reason, journalists did not report the circumstances surrounding his loan to the “Gulls”. Local supporters accepted the name “the man with the golden left foot” as they had with the team’s nom-de-plume, “The Gulls”.

Yet Don was recorded as “on loan for a brief interlude”, as in 1949 he did not disappoint fans when scoring an accumulated thirteen goals for Torquay United in only thirty-four games played. Importantly, he had earned a huge number of supporters, some of whom became friends.

Being a quiet, unassuming player, his supporters started to create a fund scheme to raise sufficient money for the club to purchase their new star, who said he loved Torbay.

Club directors were soon in discussions about a possible transfer of Don to Torquay United, although, having completed his year contract to the “Gulls”, he now moved to Cardiff City Football Club in early 1951. There he only played once for them before being transferred (poached perhaps) to Leeds United Football Team. Later it was reported they had paid a staggering £12,000 for the transfer, which, bearing in mind Don was a relatively new star, was amazing.

His transfer to Leeds United commenced in 1951, but this was terminated in 1952, a short period where he still scored ten goals in thirty-four matches. Perhaps the man with the “golden left foot” had still been a good investment for Leeds United, as Don was still only in his mid-twenties.

One journalist recorded: “Don Mills was acknowledged as the finest player in the lower divisions” and later the football scout Dave Mangrell (a former Leeds United player) wrote: “Mills' signing by QPR was a pivotal step, transitioning Mills from amateur play to the professional ranks (QPR & Leeds) during a time when football still offered a vital escape from Yorkshire’s post-war toil”.

Don returned to Torquay United once the directors had agreed a transfer fee of £5,000. It seems Don had expressed a wish to be permanently returned to Torbay.

Now he enjoyed playing some three hundred and eight appearances for the “Gulls” between 1952-1962, scoring sixty-eight goals during his second period at the club. He eventually became captain of the club and was also part of the team playing the memorable Cup match of 1955, which involved a third-round replay against Don’s northern team, Leeds United, which Torquay eventually won.

Torquay’s team were doubly fortunate that year, as the 1955 Cup match was one of the very first matches ever televised.

In 1962 Don decided to take early retirement after the team were relegated from Division Three (South) to Division Four. He had by then amassed 367 games for Torquay while scoring a total of 84 goals in all.

While still loving Torbay, he continued to reside here while being made Torquay United Football Coach and also was its “scout” through to 1970. Having spent virtually ten years on the staff as official coach, ultimately it ended as a cost-cutting exercise when the whole reserve team were axed.

Now he would spend roughly a decade before his final retirement. Initially he described himself as Torquay’s “softest traffic warden” before leaving this job as a street warden to take up work as a warden of a retirement home for teachers. It was undoubtedly more appropriate for a man described as “a real gentleman and much respected”.

A final tribute to Don came in 1998 when the Herald Express local poll entitled “Local Hero” saw Don Mills of Torquay United being voted the “greatest ever player” by his huge “band of fans”.

Sadly, having died in February 1994, he never knew of this accolade.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice