Can Torquay’s town centre reinvent itself?


As online retail continues to reshape shopping habits, the challenge is no longer how to save the high street, but how to create vibrant town centres fit for modern life
How often do I go into the centre of Torquay or Paignton shopping? The answer is “not a lot”. I either shop at The Willows or online. I am not alone, which is why there are so many charity and vape shops but very little else in the town centre. When I do go in, it is for services I cannot get online, such as the optician. I may even have a cup of coffee or go to the cinema.
As a child in the 1950s and 60s, I remember my parents going to the butcher, the greengrocer and the dairy. The idea of self-service seemed bizarre. Surely it will encourage shoplifting.
Today, I do not even meet a checkout operator. I simply scan the barcodes and the machine at the checkout does the rest. Looking at the number of people in today’s supermarkets, if we were still served personally over the counter by a friendly greengrocer, the queues would be out the door. There are still small shops with a personal service, but these offer a more boutique, expensive range.
My father was a keen amateur artist. One day he went into the bank when the cashier said, “Mr Moore, the manager wants to see you.” This sounded worrying until he went into the office where there was one of the manager’s paintings.
“Can I have your opinion? Do you think this is good enough to enter into the annual exhibition?”
I cannot imagine an ATM painting a picture and then asking for an opinion from a customer. This personal relationship probably led to a better understanding of the finances of the customers than today’s online questioners, but sadly it is not coming back.
In the past, politicians have suggested that this can all be fixed by some minor adjustments, including to business rates, or throwing money at the problem. The difficulty is that these ideas do not work. They do not tackle the underlying problem. As long as people can sit at home and arrange a delivery the next day, why go into the town centre?
When the queen of the High Street, Mary Portas, was recruited to save the town centres, she came up with a plan which was implemented in twelve town centres. Sadly, shops in these pilot areas continued to close at the same rate.
Is there a future for our high streets or even Union and Victoria Street? This is a national problem. Encouraging more shops is not the answer. If we want to bring life back to our town centres, we need a mixture of hospitality venues and housing.
Torbay Council plan to redevelop Union Square in Torquay to provide 100 new homes and healthcare provisions. There will still be a few retail sites and the Pannier Market will be refurbished. It is unclear exactly what the healthcare facility will be. Ideally, a new GP surgery, but recruitment of GPs is currently very difficult. Because GPs own their own surgeries and are self-employed, a new surgery would require doctors willing to run the business. Most newly trained GPs are looking for a salaried post.
The latest plans for the development of the old Debenhams site on Torquay Harbour have now had planning permission for a hotel, restaurants and cafes. No one suggested another department store. This new development should really improve the area.
It is hypocritical to long for a revival of the town centre whilst ordering everything online. Many small specialist shops were put out of business when people came in for advice before ordering it online. The online products could even be cheaper than the wholesale price paid by a small shopkeeper. When all the products come from an automated warehouse in the country, there are less overheads than a shop in the town centre.
It is easy to reminisce over the old days. Why can’t we have our busy shopping centre back? For better or worse, the world has moved on. This is like hoping we can go back to dial phones, landlines or cars which don’t keep going bleep as I drive. I may no longer drive into Torquay town centre for shopping, but in the future I may enjoy a drink and a meal looking over the harbour. That will be more appealing than sitting outside an empty Debenhams.