Water bosses told: Cancel 'unfair' trial

placeholder image

3,500 businesses and homes have been selected by South West Water to take part in a scheme which will see the price they pay for their water reduced in winter, but significantly increased in the summer

A seasonal water tariff trial, which has provoked outcry amongst residents forced to take part, has been challenged by Torbay Councillors who backed residents’ concerns.

While South West Water say that the trial is”fair” and “for the benefit of our customers”, residents on the trial have blasted the plan for being the opposite.

3,500 businesses and homes have been selected by South West Water to take part in a scheme which will see the price they pay for their water reduced in winter, but significantly increased in the summer months. It was claimed the aim of the trial is to reduce water usage via increasing the cost of using water, yet South West Water has confirmed all properties selected were already fitted with water metres.

A representative from the water company appeared before Torbay Council’s Overview & Scrutiny Board to answer questions about the trial and hear Councillor’s concerns. It was revealed 347 Torbay homes are being forced to take part in the new charging scheme.

The trial started on 1st October, but the price to be paid next summer will not be confirmed until February. South West Water conceded up to 45% of those involved will pay more, for the same amount of water usage, under the trial.

One resident from Brixham criticised the trial for being compulsory.

“If there was real savings to be made on this new tariff, then there would be people queuing up to trial it. The fact that they are forcing us to take part says it all really.”

Following close questioning, it emerged Torbay’s Lib Dem MP had been offered a bespoke briefing by South West Water ahead of the trial starting, whilst Torbay Council, local Councillors, businesses and residents were not consulted. The trial has been supported by national regulator OFWAT, but the Cross-Party panel of Councillors voted to write to the Chief Executive of South West Water expressing their concerns over the way the trial has been implemented.

Ahead of the meeting a group of residents and Cllr Hazel Foster joined a protest outside Torquay Town Hall.

Cllr Hazel Foster (Con, Wellswood) said: “Residents are right to be angry about being placed on a new water tariff without meaningful consultation or the right to opt out, they have not even been told what they will be charged next summer. South West Water must go back to the drawing board and cancel this unfair experiment.”

South West Water said that the roll out of the new trial was “fair”, and that the water company would help people in saving water and therefore money. However, there was no guarantee that the new tariff would save customers money.

In response to the trial being compulsory, South West Water said that it wanted the trial to “cross all demographics of customers”, so that it can gather “qualitative and quantitative data to see if it is a success which we hope it will be.”

SWW continued: “We will of course listen to any customer who may not want to take part in the trial.

“All feedback is valuable feedback. We hope that our customers will want to remain part of this so that we can help people to only pay for the water they use. Customers told us they wanted new and fairer ways of being billed for their water use, we have heard them loud and clear which is why this trial is launching in October.”

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice