Torquay harbour hotel plan goes to planners as Bay tries to navigate way through world challenges including Mr Trump!

Torquay harbour hotel planplaceholder image
Torquay harbour hotel plan

Hospital parking deal may unlock investment but councillor still has fears for future

I wonder where Torbay would be and what it would look like if we hadn’t suffered the consequences of literally world-changing events like Covid, the war in Ukraine, a cost of living crisis, fuel poverty, the war in Iran and anything else that mad man in the White House might be about to conjure up and throw at us?

Like it or not, these phenomenons have had a major impact on local, UK and worldwide economies, knocking consumers and, more importantly, investor confidence for six.

The timing could not have been worse or more challenging for the Bay as millions and millions of pounds came into the English Riviera through government funding and a public/private sector regeneration partnership between Torbay Council and developers Willmott Dixon and Milligan.

Key sites have been identified, primarily across declining town centre areas, for massive regeneration projects. The global happenings have taken their toll as the development partners face a one-step forward, two steps back scenario.

To be fair this has had nothing to do with politics. There has been cross–party support for the massive regeneration plans and there have been those bumps in the road under different administrations at the Town Hall. Progress and pace has been affected. It was always going to be and nobody is to blame apart from Mr T of course!

Last week I wrote about a deal struck between Torbay Council and the Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust to release land on the outskirts of Torquay for car parking for Torbay Hospital.

Not only will the land provide much-needed parking in the interim, but longer term it will also enable the health trust to reconfigurate the main hospital site including potentially the building of a new multi-storey car park.

The NHS is also seen as a crucial partner in those bigger High Street regeneration schemes when it comes to health hub space and key sector worker accommodation, taking out some of those bumps in the progress road at the same time.

Independent and ward councillor Darren Cowell, who played a leading role in the administration that ran the council before the current Tories, is against the Edgwinswell deal because it entails land which has been earmarked for employment and jobs.

He is also concerned about the time projects are taking to progress and fears the land in question will remain a car park in the years to come.

Cllr Cowell says: “Your column extols the virtues of partnership working between the council and the NHS Trust. Be in no doubt I am 100 per cent supportive of the initiatives that are being discussed, mainly because I was part of an administration that first explored such initiatives. That was between 2019 and 2023.

“One of the earliest projects to be agreed in August, 2020 was the provision of a solar farm at Nightingale Park to provide direct energy to the hospital site. Roll the clock forward and nothing has happened. Why? Because the NHS hasn’t signed a deal (I have been promised it is imminent, but that will be almost six years in the making).

“Then the partnership administration took the decision to purchase Union Square. We did so in the knowledge that retail was facing continued decline and recognising the strategic importance of owning regeneration sites.

“Early proposals included the provision of health care within the development and provision of much needed social rented homes. Roll on another four years and nothing has been agreed.

“Then there is Victoria Square, where we are told there could be further collaboration with the hospital. So far, all talk and no contracts.”

He adds: “Coming to my concerns about the flogging off the land at Edginswell. Torbay’s current and emerging Local Plan clearly designates the site as employment land, as does the Torquay Neighbourhood Plan which was overwhelmingly approved by a public referendum.

“Torbay has very few quality employment sites and given the bay’s ambition to be known as a high quality, hi-tech provider of research and development and manufacturing sites such as Edginswell are key.

“If one of our businesses based at the EPIC centre in Paignton was looking to expand and the EPIC II site was full, the chances are that they would up sticks and move elsewhere.

“Indeed, a further column in last week’s Torbay Weekly also celebrates the success of the high-tech sector and reports that they are looking for a third EPIC site of some 40,000 square feet. Here’s an idea, what about Edginswell. Doesn’t anyone link these things up?”

He adds: “All this talk about using the land as a transition facility to enable the building of a multi-story on the hospital site is pie in the sky. Such talk has been going on for at least 20 years and the planned major redevelopment of the hospital has been delayed until beyond 2030.

“If the hospital should move quickly and identify a scheme on the main site, there is the little matter of planning permission and consultation – and given that there has been no exploratory talks with residents or local councillors (I am one of them along with Cllr Katya Maddison), my suspicion is that we are months, if not years, away from such a scheme.

“My fear is that in five years’ time the hospital will ask the council to extend the current ‘temporary’ car park for a further five years and the valuable employment land will remain a car park and lost opportunity.”

He adds: “I have made my views clear that this is a poor decision taken by a poor Cabinet. A Cabinet that promised delivery on regeneration and so far, all we have seen is the demolition of multi-story car parks to create – yep – car parks.

In the column, Cllr Chris Lewis (the Cabinet member responsible for regeneration (sic)) refers to the land being leased – it is not a lease – it is a sale. He also says the land has been derelict for 15 years.

“Well, I recognise that he represents a Paignton ward, but if he hadn’t noticed the land benefited from a government grant to prepare it for development. The land is level and sat waiting for real investment to provide added valued jobs. I’m sure the government will not be impressed to learn that the levelling works they paid for have now benefited a car park. What makes this dithering even more unpalatable is the multi-millions of pounds spent on external private experts to speed up delivery. Experts who are receiving a handsome cheque each month averaging £250,000! But more on that another day.”

Deputy council leader Chris Lewis, also in charge of regeneration, revealed the health trust at this very moment has a proposal from the council for the Nightingale Park solar farm a response is awaited.

He adds: “The land has been empty at Edginswell for 15 years. We don’t have people queuing up to go there. If we did it would be different.”

Cllr Lewis said Cllr Cowell and the previous administration faced some tough decisions when they were in charge like buying Union Square, the Debenhams site and Fleet Walk.

“They did what they had to do under the difficult circumstances but we were left to pick up the pieces. You still have to make sure these projects stack up financially.”

He added: “None of these deals stacked up in the private environment. That is why the council had to step in. I don’t think the council should be doing any of these schemes but we have to because in the current circumstances they are not viable out in the private sector. That is why the government has also stepped in to help with £100million funding. It is frustrating all around.”

Chris Wheeler, national head of development at Willmott Dixon, gave an update on the regeneration programme, which will create hundreds of jobs and generate many millions of pounds for the Bay’s economy, at this week’s Torbay Business Forum breakfast meeting.

He said schemes ARE progressing — with Union Square, the NHS are being asked to confirm a partnership and move in early so work can start next year; at Crossways in Paignton work should start later this year; a new fish quay expansion is moving forward at Brixham.

He talked of ‘phased developments’ at Union Square and Victoria Square in Paignton.

And of the four-star harbour hotel plan for Debenhams, shortly after the Forum meeting at the Arena came this news from Torbay Council: “We have now submitted the formal planning application for The Strand, a 154‑-bedroom hotel and commercial space on Torquay’s harbourside, for determination by the local planning authority. The application is currently undergoing validation before it appears on the planning portal.

“This represents a significant milestone in Torbay’s regeneration partnership journey with Willmott Dixon and Milligan and marks the third major project planning submission in just two and a half years.”

The council added: “The outcome of this application is expected to be known later this year.”

Let’s hope that is sooner rather than later!

So, you see there is movement and hope. If we can land one scheme others will follow — despite dear old Donald in Washington.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice