Torbay mum having to relive tragedy of daughter's death eight years ago


A letter from the hospital where her daughter died eight years ago has brought distressing memories flooding back for a Torquay mum
A distraught Torbay mother is having to relive the devastating heartache of her young daughter’s death eight years ago after an ‘out-of-the-blue’ letter from the hospital where she died.
The letter to Sarah Loram revealed how tissue samples taken from a post mortem of her daughter Alice which are still being held by the Bristol Children’s Hospital where the 14-year-old died in 2018.
Sarah, who lives at the Willows in Torquay, knew a post mortem would be carried out after former Combe Pafford schoolgirl Alice died but she had no idea body samples were still at Bristol. She has since discovered that tissue samples are also being stored at Newcastle Hospital where other tests were carried out.
At one stage Sarah even feared she had buried her daughter without her heart and brain and asked herself: “Do I exhume her and put all this back with her? It is as if she has died all over again. Do I have to bury her all over again? I know it does not make sense but nothing makes sense.”
She added: “I felt I was right back there when Alice died. It has brought it all rushing back.”


The Human Tissue Authority, which regulates establishments carrying out post mortems, is looking into the case.
The Bristol hospitals trust says it is ‘very sorry to hear of the distress that Ms Loram has experienced after receiving our letter’.
Alice’s death made national headlines when Avon coroner Dr Simon Fox said at the time that doctors could have prevented her suffering a fatal heart attack after an MRI scan at Torbay Hospital if they had diagnosed her earlier.
Dr Fox said the decision not to seek further guidance on her genetic condition led to her "dying unexpectedly and prematurely". He said the cause of death was because her "medical management was lacking".
The inquest heard Alice was under the care of hormone specialists from Bristol Children's Hospital, and had a condition which made her heart more than twice as big as it should have been which put her in danger when anaesthetised.
But she was given an anaesthetic before the scan in October, 2018, after becoming "extremely anxious" and "hypersensitive".
Throughout her life she had been prescribed growth hormone, but her parents and doctors did not know the reason for her shortness. Her parents said they had repeatedly warned doctors they were concerned about a range of symptoms, including breathlessness.
The coroner said four medical causes contributed to her death - mitochondrial disease, multiple organ failure, myocardial fibrosis and heart failure during the anaesthetic.
Returning a narrative verdict, Dr Fox said Alice had been seen by a range of specialists over a nine-year period for her different conditions.
"But she was not referred to investigation of an underlying disorder, specifically a clinical geneticist's opinion, despite her parents requesting this on at least two separate occasions.
"The evidence demonstrated that as a result her underlying condition, and specifically a serious cardiomyopathy, went undiagnosed resulting in her dying unexpectedly and prematurely as a result of a routine general anaesthetic."
Sarah said: “The MRI was because Alice was getting extremely bad headaches which were a side effect to the growth hormone. They believed she may have had water on the brain. The post mortem revealed she did not.”


Sarah, who was married and called Sloman at the time, has battled to put her life back together after losing Alice. The tragedy cost her her marriage and affected other members of her family. She was winning that fight until the letter from the University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation Trust dropped through her letterbox just a few weeks ago.
It confirmed: “During your child’s care at Bristol Royal Hospital for Children, a small number of tissue samples were kept. In some cases these samples can be important in the future to help clarify or confirm a diagnosis that could not be fully established at the time of death or support further specialist testing if new information or tests become available. We are therefore asking whether you would be willing to give consent for the ongoing storage of your child’s post mortem samples.”
Sarah said: “The letter came out of the blue. It was a generic letter directed at somebody who had gone through an autopsy of a loved one.”
A post mortem was held on Alice who was on life support for three days in Bristol. Tests were carried out including on Alice’s heart which was sent to Newcastle.
In January, 2019, Sarah was told her daughter’s body was intact and a funeral could go ahead. Alice was buried three-and-a-half months after she died in the teenager's area at Hele Cemetery under a street light ‘so she is never in the dark’.
But the recent letter has sent doubts whirling in Sarah’s head. “They have kept her in a lab for eight years. It might not seem so much to people but when you wait so long to bury your daughter with dignity that she deserves the fact that they have kept this thing in a lab for eight years is horrific. I thought she was back together. I’ve got this letter. They had no right to keep what they have without my consent. They sent me the letter just to brush it under the carpet.
“Whatever happens they are not keeping it. I don't know what they have done with it and whether she is being treated like some sort of lab rat in a hospital.”
She added: “Newcastle have just called. They had samples of her heart, not her whole heart, but also muscle and skin cells. They still have samples left and DNA stored from her heart tissue and skin cultures and some vials of cells.
“I have no idea how to feel about this right now. Yes they may be doing good to find cures but I also didn't know it was there again without my consent.
“Apparently no examination or experimental stuff has been done on them since. They are just in cold storage. They said they store them indefinitely. It’s just what they do. But again I didn't know, they asked if I wanted them destroyed. I said no not at this time.”


Sarah says she was offered little support after Alice’s death. “I was offered some counselling help. I get letters from Torbay Hospital to go to meetings for families that have lost children, but I do not want to sit in a room with lots of grieving people,” she says.
Sarah spent time ‘building a case’ after Alice died. She had a private meeting with then Prime Minister Boris Johnson when he visited Torbay Hospital during Covid. She also had a meeting with then Health Minister Stephen Hammond which was organised by former Torbay MP Kevin Foster.
She was looking to launch a national campaign forcing medics to carry out ECG tests on young people before they are given anaesthetic.
But Alice’s passing and the timing of the pandemic took its toll. Sarah suffered a breakdown. Her three other children, Romeo, now 14, Amber 20 and Jake 27 were also affected.
Sara says: “My marriage broke down. I left my husband because I was so angry. I was signed off work for life.”
She said: “I rebuilt my life around helping my children and they are doing really well. I got my degree. The last eight years have been tough but the past few years I have really worked on myself. My life had some sort of medium where I could find peace and live with this gut-wrenching ordeal. When something like losing a child that kind of hurt never goes away but you find some way to live with the indignity of it.”


But she said: “I thought I had found peace but now it has gone. I do not understand how they can be so cruel and gross. Since the end of May all those horrible feelings have come back again. I am going through a really tough time. The peace has gone. It has been shattered. They have upended my life so much again. I have to relive it all again just because somebody could not do their job properly. I have suffered a massive ordeal and I am now suffering again because of their mistakes.”
Sarah has complained to the Bristol health trust and to the Human Tissue Authority. She has also met current Torbay MP Steve Darling to discuss the situation.
A spokesman for the Human Tissues Authority said: “The HTA's licensing standards, Codes of Practice and guidance set clear expectations for all establishments we regulate, including the safe storage and use of tissues and cells with proper consent.
“HTA are aware of the case and asked the HTA Post Mortem licence holder (University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust) to report this to us as a Human Tissue Authority Reporting Incident.”
The process is that the establishment holding the post mortem licence conducts an investigation. They have two months to complete that investigation and will report back to the Human Tissue Authority. They may also report back to their own establishment or organisation for instance through board meeting minutes.
It is not clear what further action may be taken if it is necessary. The HTA says it cannot comment on individual cases but in general terms it will look at the report and may offer advice to reduce risks for similar incidents. They also have the power to carry out unannounced inspections which have been taking place in the post mortem sector
Dr Rebecca Thorpe, Medical Director, City Centre and Weston Hospital Operating Unit at the Bristol health trust, said: "We are very sorry to hear of the distress that Mrs Loram has experienced after receiving our letter and we are taking her concerns incredibly seriously.
"We are in the process of investigating the circumstances relating to the tissue sample and will continue to support Mrs Loram throughout this process.
"We are unable to comment further but would like to reassure families and loved ones that the respect and dignity of those in our care is our highest priority."
Torbay MP Mr Darling’s office said: “After the constituent wrote to the Human Tissue Authority, Steve wrote to the Minister for Health and Social Care three weeks ago but has not yet received a response.
“Steve wrote asking if anyone else had experienced this particular problem and asking the Minister to respond with the scale of the issue.”
Sarah is determined in her latest battle: “I am highlighting this to stop others going through what I am. I will work it out - I have Romeo, Jake and my Amber.”