Torbay MPs demand immediate ban on water company bonuses after South West Water fine

placeholder image

It comes as the new government’s Water Bill is set to be debated in Parliament

Torbay’s MPs Steve Darling and Caroline Voaden have both called for an immediate ban on executive bonuses for England’s water companies following the announcement that South West Water (SWW) would have to pay back £17.4 million due to poor performance.

It comes as the new government’s Water Bill is set to be debated in Parliament.

The new Water Bill seeks to strengthen the power of water industry regulators and puts failing water companies under special measures.

Enforcement powers include giving regulators the power to take faster and tougher action against water companies that damage the environment through new penalties including fines, bonus restrictions and even imprisonment.

The Liberal Democrats have said the bill is only a “half-measure” and will table an amendment that would enforce an immediate ban on water company bosses’ bonuses.

Last year, Torbay saw 570 sewage spills, amounting to 4,398 hours. This is the latest data available and uses the old constituency boundaries.

Sewage pollution tends to be a result of heavy rain, overwhelming the system and triggering South West Water to discharge raw sewage into the sea to prevent it from backing up in the pipes and spilling back into the homes and businesses that created it.

While the discharges are often legal, there has been intense scrutiny around the frequency of sewage spills and accountability around ‘dry’ spills, where sewage continues to be discharged in dry conditions.

Local Liberal Democrat MP, Steve Darling said that the steps by the regulator announced today needed to be a “watershed” moment for South West Water and that it was “high time” action was taken on these polluting firms.

Steve added: “For too long the Conservatives allowed water companies to ride roughshod over people. Here in Torbay, we’ve had sewage releases onto our beaches and a cryptosporidium outbreak in Brixham and south of Paignton earlier in the year.  All the while the bosses are taking home massive bonuses.

“That must end. No longer should these people be personally rewarded for failing to protect our local environment all whilst hiking bills on people in our area.”

In the much more rural constituency of South Devon (previously Totnes), which includes Brixham and other villages in Torbay, spills were much higher. Last year the area saw 5,279 spills, amounting to 52,344 hours.

Caroline Voaden, also a Liberal Democrat, said that she found the new bill “disappointing”.

Voaden was also part of a recent panel meeting with Brixham residents, which saw SWW Chief Executive Susan Davy answer questions about the cryptosporidium questions publicly for the first time. Media were banned from the event and coverage was strictly censored.

On the bill, Voaden continued: “The new government’s bill is only a half-measure and nowhere near tough enough on these polluting firms.

“That is why I am proud to support the Liberal Democrats amendment to the bill, which would ban water company bosses' bonuses until leaks are fixed and sewage spills end. Only then will we start to get a fair deal for people here in Torbay.”

A SWW spokesperson has previously said: "WaterFit is our plan to protect rivers and seas together. WaterFit will dramatically reduce our use of storm overflows, maintain our region’s excellent bathing water quality standards all year round and reduce and then remove our impact on river water quality by 2030.

"Working with partners and customers, WaterFit will begin to deliver the change we all want to see."

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice