Torbay Council's housing plan 'out of date' and falling short, minister warns

Torbay's draft local plan, published for consultation last November, would meet just 42 per cent of the area's housing need, leaving a shortfall of nearly 11,000 homes.  placeholder image
Torbay's draft local plan, published for consultation last November, would meet just 42 per cent of the area's housing need, leaving a shortfall of nearly 11,000 homes. | Unsplash

The Housing Minister has asked Torbay Council to hand over evidence within three weeks after its draft local plan was found to meet less than half of the area's housing need.

The government has issued a stinging rebuke to Torbay Council, warning it faces direct ministerial intervention over its local plan, in a strongly-worded letter from Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook to council leader Councillor David Thomas.

At the heart of the minister's concerns is Torbay's draft local plan, published for public consultation last November, which he says would meet just 42 per cent of the area's Local Housing Need, leaving a shortfall of 10,980 homes over the plan period.

David Thomas, leader of Torbay Councilplaceholder image
David Thomas, leader of Torbay Council

For a plan to pass legal scrutiny, Mr Pennycook writes, it must be “positively prepared, justified, effective, and consistent with national policy”, providing a strategy which “as a minimum, seeks to meet the area's housing needs.”Torbay's draft, he says, falls short of that bar.

Compounding those concerns, the minister says the council has yet to publish a key document establishing which sites in the area could realistically be built on.

Without it, he writes, “it is not possible to reach a conclusion on whether the Council has taken a sufficiently robust approach to the identification of suitable sites for development and, therefore, whether the plan stands a reasonable chance of being found sound at examination.”

He adds that the council has “failed to respond to enquiries” from his officials about when that document would be released. Mr Pennycook has issued a formal legal direction under section 27(2)(b) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004, ordering the council to hand over a substantial package of evidence within three weeks.

Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook placeholder image
Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook

In his own words, he is directing the council “to submit to me all available evidence-based documents which inform your conclusion that only 42% of local housing need can be met through your emerging plan.”That includes an updated Housing and Economic Land Availability Assessment, incorporating sites put forward in the most recent Call for Sites in 2025, along with “any relevant studies the council has commissioned on matters such as constraints, residential densities, impacts on National Landscape or other landscape impacts, and any housing-related topic papers that the Council has produced to date.”The minister was unambiguous about what follows if the council does not comply:

I will not hesitate to take further action if this request is not complied with.” Mr Pennycook says the council's low housing requirement, “combined with the aforementioned lack of published evidence to support this approach, meets the legal threshold for intervention.” The backdrop makes the warning all the more serious. Torbay's current local plan dates from 2015, meaning its policies are, in the minister's own words, “likely to be out of date.”

The council's latest Housing Delivery Test score of 66 per cent already places it in what the government calls the “presumption in favour of sustainable development”, leaving it vulnerable to speculative planning applications; it may have limited power to refuse.

Torbay Council confirmed to the Torbay Weekly that it had received the letter.

Councillor Chris Lewis, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Place Development and Economic Growth, said the council had “engaged positively” with the government throughout the plan-making process and would respond by 2 July.“We will also be submitting the exceptional circumstances information to the Government for the 24 June deadline to outline our case,” he added.

The minister had offered the council until 24 June to set out any reasons why intervention would be inappropriate, though he was careful to stress this “neither alters nor removes the direction” already issued.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice