The Storyteller: How we can still hear cries of the mayor executed for stealing sheep

placeholder image

In my opinion, there are four main challenges to walkers on Dartmoor who do Letterboxing like myself. These challenges are the three main locations where permanent boxes have been sited: Fur Tor, Ducks Pool, the Mecca of Cranmere Pool, and the long trek to Red Lake Tip in the center of the south moor.

Last year, some friends and I took on the Red Lake Tip challenge the day after my 60th birthday. Just before that, we made the trip to Fur Tor, and just before I reached my next decade, I saw a sunset from the highest Dartmoor ridge, which contains Yes Tor and High Willhays. In September, the plan is to visit Ducks Pool again, showing it off to some who haven’t been there before. However, the other Sunday, I took my friend Colin to see Cranmere Pool for the first time.placeholder image
Last year, some friends and I took on the Red Lake Tip challenge the day after my 60th birthday. Just before that, we made the trip to Fur Tor, and just before I reached my next decade, I saw a sunset from the highest Dartmoor ridge, which contains Yes Tor and High Willhays. In September, the plan is to visit Ducks Pool again, showing it off to some who haven’t been there before. However, the other Sunday, I took my friend Colin to see Cranmere Pool for the first time.

I’ve been to Cranmere Pool several times over the years. The first attempt, with some friends who I dragged all the way from Belstone, ended in us failing to find it. But it showed me that you could park closer, as in those days you could leave a car at Observation Post 15 before making the trickier last lap on foot. I then achieved my goal on my own the following week... I don’t like to let a Letterbox hunt defeat me! Since then, I’ve been with other groups of friends, the most memorable occasion being a time the three of us got overtaken by a blanket of fog! No harm done—you just keep heading north, and you soon hit the army ring road...

On this recent visit, we parked at Row Tor, the closest you can get on this stretch of track these days. This time, the weather was kind to us, being not too hot and with no rain, just right for a long Dartmoor walk.

Setting off, we soon reached New Bridge, over Black-a-ven Brook, below the heights of East Mill Tor. Continuing on, the main route is bisected by what is known as Sammy Arnold’s Lane. No one knows who Sammy Arnold was, or what he did to deserve having one of the army tracks named after him, but one suggestion is that he may have been an old peat cutter back when peat was big business on Dartmoor.

Over the next rise, you come to Observation Post 15, one of many army command points used to oversee activity on the ranges and to make sure no animals or humans stray onto them during live firing exercises. From here, you follow a muddy track to Ockerton Court, a large pool surrounded by peat banks. The difference between this and Cranmere Pool is that the Court has water in it...

Now comes the hard part. You have to take a bearing due south and keep going, hopping boggy parts and trying to find tracks through the drier areas. To your right is the depression of the West Okement River Valley as it nears its source close to the pool. Ahead is just boggy wilderness, so you have to hope you don’t overshoot the target. To the left stands an army hut on top of Hangingstone Hill, and looking at the map, your destination is just beyond it. Fortunately, Colin had an app on his phone tracking our progress, so we knew when we were in the right ballpark.placeholder image
Now comes the hard part. You have to take a bearing due south and keep going, hopping boggy parts and trying to find tracks through the drier areas. To your right is the depression of the West Okement River Valley as it nears its source close to the pool. Ahead is just boggy wilderness, so you have to hope you don’t overshoot the target. To the left stands an army hut on top of Hangingstone Hill, and looking at the map, your destination is just beyond it. Fortunately, Colin had an app on his phone tracking our progress, so we knew when we were in the right ballpark.

As we finally drew level, I spotted the top of the concrete “cupboard” that contains the holy grail of Letterboxing: the visitor's book and the trio of stamps that have been used over the years to denote that you have made it to the birthplace of the greatest hobby ever!

James Perrott was a moorland guide who operated his business out of Chagford. In 1854, he had the bright idea of building a small cairn out of stones at Cranmere Pool, placing a bottle in it, and then persuading his guests to insert a business card to be retrieved and added to by his next customers. Business cards became postcards, to be returned to the leaver. This then spread to other spots on Dartmoor, and now the moorland is covered in plastic containers with rubber stamps inside, along with a notebook so you can leave your own stamp and message, whilst taking a copy of the resident stamp for your own, ever-growing collection... I’ve lost count of how many I have...

Colin and I took a moment to examine the contents of the box, while adding our names to the book. This latest version dates back to 2021, my previous visits all being prior to that. We are in good company, for previous signees allegedly include famous writers such as Charles Dickens, Charles Kingsley, R.D. Blackmore, and even our very own King Charles III once paid a visit. Old books are now kept on display in Plymouth Museum. Once, one book went missing/stolen, and even though a £2 reward was offered (a lot of money in those days), it was sadly never returned...

I mentioned earlier that the pool no longer has any water in it, and this might have something to do with the legend of Benjamin Geare...

Benjie, who according to his Latin memorial plaque preserved in the vestry of All Saints Church in Okehampton, somewhere that we visit during my Ghost Walk around the town, was elected to the office of Mayor of Okehampton five times but only got to serve four. He was unable to serve his fifth term as he was found guilty of sheep stealing, sentenced to death, and hung on Hangingstone Hill far from the town, presumably so his spirit couldn’t return to disturb his constituents.

Unfortunately for them, that’s exactly what he did! He made such a nuisance of himself that the local priest was called in to exorcise him. In doing so, he banished Benjie to Cranmere Pool and made him perform the impossible task of emptying the water with a sieve, one of those punishments that folklore loves to bestow on particularly wicked people in death. However, Benjie wasn’t to be easily beaten, and taking the fleece off a nearby sheep’s carcass, he wrapped it around the sieve, thus allowing him to complete the task in double quick time. He then made his way back to his beloved town to create more havoc for the living.placeholder image
Unfortunately for them, that’s exactly what he did! He made such a nuisance of himself that the local priest was called in to exorcise him. In doing so, he banished Benjie to Cranmere Pool and made him perform the impossible task of emptying the water with a sieve, one of those punishments that folklore loves to bestow on particularly wicked people in death. However, Benjie wasn’t to be easily beaten, and taking the fleece off a nearby sheep’s carcass, he wrapped it around the sieve, thus allowing him to complete the task in double quick time. He then made his way back to his beloved town to create more havoc for the living.

This time, the troubled townsfolk pulled out the big guns, calling upon the Archbishop to rid them of this meddlesome spirit. He, in turn, summoned a local stable boy to bring him a black stallion. He then cast Benjie’s spirit into the horse, instructing the lad to ride him back to Cranmere Pool. Why Cranmere Pool? Well, I can only imagine that as his life was taken on nearby Hangingstone Hill, this was the nearest most convenient and remotest pit to leave him in. As the stallion was about to be ridden at speed into the pool, the stable boy leapt off to safety and watched in amazement as the horse disappeared into the depths of the now-empty pool. With one final cry of frustration, Benjamin Geare was no more. Some say that if the wind is in the right direction, you can still hear Benjie’s cries, but sadly during our visit, he wasn’t being very vocal.

The unfortunate thing about a visit to Cranmere Pool is that, once you’ve rested up, just like the lad in the legend, you’ve got to make your way back to where you started, on foot!

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice