Storyteller: The legacy of TV's Most Haunted

placeholder image

I was recently flicking through the latest brochure from my old place of work, the Princess Theatre, when I spotted that Most Haunted are bringing a stage show there later in the year, showcasing their top ten scariest locations that they’ve investigated.

I was recently flicking through the latest brochure from my old place of work, the Princess Theatre, when I spotted that Most Haunted are bringing a stage show there later in the year, showcasing their top ten scariest locations that they’ve investigated.

Now many people might get excited by this, sitting through clips of the TV show, and I’m sure they will get a decent audience, but I always get mixed emotions whenever this name crops up.

I’m sure they started the TV series with the best of intentions, bringing the idea of exploring haunted properties to a wider audience, and encouraging the public to become ghost hunters.

When the first series aired in 2002, I had already been running my group, Torbay Investigators of the Paranormal (TIP), for seven years. People came to our meetings to share their experiences, seeking possible answers to what had happened to them.

Some joined us when we visited local haunted properties, and the owners welcomed us with open arms, as they too wanted to know what we might find.

Then along came Most Haunted, prepared to pay big money to gain access to these buildings and make their TV programmes. Suddenly, we found ourselves being asked to pay silly money to be able to spend the night in these properties, whereas before it had been free.

I wasn’t prepared to start paying for the privilege of sitting around in the dark, and I wasn’t about to ask my members to pay either, but there were other groups that were willing, all having sprung up online, in the wake of Most Haunted coming on TV.

The first season had been of interest, as it just showed the team turning up at locations, carrying out investigations, along with their medium, Derek Acorah, showing their findings beside the history of the property and the known hauntings.

This must have been too tame for the producers of the show, for by the second series they had obviously asked Derek to spice things up a bit, and we started to get his 'possession of the week', whereby he claimed to be channelling the spirit of a resident ghost, but in a very dramatic way that looked good for the cameras.

Derek always made a feature of his communication with his spirit guide, Sam, who helped him link in with the messages he shared and kept him safe from such possessions, so why would Sam let him down now? This, combined with the constant screaming of the presenters, and their dubious out of shot antics, soon put me off the programme.

My scepticism came to a head when they chose Torbay as a location for one of their live, weekend long, broadcasts, using the leisure centre at Clennon Valley as their hub, where they monitored their investigations in front of a live studio audience.

Myself, and members of my group, were invited to be part of that audience on the Monday night. Prior to that, we stayed glued to our TV screens to see what they came up with, sadly it was such a disappointment. On the first night they were at Lupton House, former home to Lord Churston, who also owned our old meeting place at Churston Court.

The highlight of this event was watching Derek down in the dingy cellar area, claiming that the spirits of the Pomeroy sisters were present. Instantly, there was an off-screen voice cautioning Derek that they would be present at Berry Pomeroy, which was to be Monday’s location!

Sure enough, when Derek got to the castle, he once again claimed the spirits of the sisters were close to him. This time he was challenged on camera by one of the researchers, saying he had said that at Lupton House. Derek feigned surprise, replying: “Did I? Well, they are definitely here now!”

This was truly risible, and, along with the behaviour of the rest of the company elsewhere, across the whole weekend, it didn’t show Most Haunted in a very good light.

Shortly after this, Derek was shown up as being a fraud, when members of the crew fed him the name 'Kreed Kafer', allegedly a South African jailer whose spirit haunted Bodmin Gaol. Derek used this name during the programme for a spirit he was picking up on, afterwards it was cruelly revealed to be an anagram of Derek Faker. He was discredited, and shortly afterwards asked to leave the programme.

This incident led to a national outcry against fake mediums giving readings for profit. In order to protect the public, a ruling was passed that all acts of mediumship, whether private or public, were to be dubbed as a source of entertainment, and not to be taken seriously.

In one stroke, Most Haunted had managed to get all mediums tarred with the same brush as Derek!

In his defence, I do believe he had a gift, for during one of his many appearances at the Princess Theatre, that I sat in on, he did ask for me by name, and proceeded to bring through my paternal grandparents, and pass on a message from them. It’s just a shame that he was lured by fame and fortune to prostitute that gift.

My last run in with Most Haunted, to date, concerns an investigation we did at the old court house in Exeter. We had been invited to check it out, before its new owners turned it into flats and a space for hire. We made an event of the occasion, by linking in to a live broadcast on John Govier’s radio show as a Halloween special.

It was a very interesting night, exploring the building with the lights out, especially in the basement cell block area, where some of my mediums picked up on the presence of some past convicts, even managing to get some names.

We all agreed this was an amazing place to investigate, so much so that my partner’s sister decided to get in touch with Most Haunted, suggesting they have a go too. They appeared very keen, even to the point of inquiring about our findings, which, at the time, were available online, so we couldn’t stop them looking, they assured us that only the researchers would see them.

Intrigued to find out what they made of the place, we tuned in, only to be totally disillusioned when their medium repeated our findings literally word for word! The one difference they had, was a claim to having found an old ship’s captain who had transported convicts to Botany Bay, whose name was Captain Phillips... not only is that my surname but also my partner’s sister too!

We took this as being their way of thanking us for allowing them to use our work! Maybe you can understand why any mention of Most Haunted tends to leave a bitter taste in my mouth!

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice