Sally Allen: Critical decisions with long-term repercussions


I become more concerned about the future of Torbay on a daily basis. While there are some very big and positive steps being taken, there are also some unfathomable situations being created by the council. I don’t know if these decisions are based on far
I become more concerned about the future of Torbay on a daily basis.
While there are some very big and positive steps being taken, there are also some unfathomable situations being created by the council.
I don’t know if these decisions are based on far more information than I have at my fingertips or if those making the decisions are just not taking all the knock-on effects into consideration.
I would like to find out, as the direction that is taken in the next few weeks will have very long-term repercussions in the Bay.
I think that the residents and businesses of Torbay have on the whole, been long suffering.
I will go back to one of my favourite whinges of parking, and the lack of it. I have never ever understood the need for a second Premier Inn in Torquay, particularly as there are always empty hotel beds in the area and the hotel wasn’t needed.
Surely, it would have been more prudent to help existing hotels upgrade their premises.
This new Premier Inn has taken away much-needed parking and is now going to cost the taxpayer even more money due to, a not unexpected, spiralling building costs resulting in a shortfall of cash.
I know first-hand how important parking is for businesses.
When I had my shop in Babbacombe Business Park, I offered free parking right outside our unit. Hence, the business boomed. We would not have moved if the cliff face hadn’t started to fall down behind us and we had to cordon off areas for health and safety reasons.
So, I moved to Torwood Street, where I thought I would do even better because the premises were so close to the central harbour area and the tourists. How wrong I was!
We didn’t take in two months what we could take in a week in Babbacombe Business Park. The reason was so clear – there was no parking.
I mention all this because there is now a major problem with the ‘Golden Mile’ in Paignton being turned into a pedestrian precinct.
To me this is more like ‘Golden Madness’.
Apart from the fact that pedestrian precincts have been proven across the UK not to work, it is also important to take into account that the Torbay area has an elderly demographic, which makes it even more important to allow shoppers to park as close as possible to their objective.
This is not rocket science - it is just common sense.
People don’t want to have to park a distance away and walk to the shops. Instead, they will shop online. It is that simple.
Again, my old hobby horse, echelon parking the length of the ‘Golden Mile’ would encourage shoppers and it would be much cheaper to create than a pedestrian precinct.
The next imminent disaster is the proposed closure of the Brixham Road.
Clearly, if this goes ahead, it will be devastating for the whole of Torbay, but catastrophic for Brixham residents and business owners.
Brixham is the most valuable fishing port in the UK and is the jewel in the crown for Torbay. If this road closure goes ahead, the body blow will be massive to the fishing industry.
Added to this, anyone needing serious medical attention will be unable to get to the Torbay Hospital. Surely, putting lives at risk cannot be an option?
The other thing that needs to be taken into consideration with both these major issues is the inclusion of a penalty clause for non-performance or contractors not completing on time.
It is normal business practise for there to be big penalties imposed for not finishing a job on time.
Just think about the Network Rail Bridge on Torbay Road. It has gone on for ages and still not finished. The Premier Inn mentioned above, is still not finished but it is the taxpayers paying the penalty, not the builders.
I realise that some of the contractors have gone bust during the pandemic and things had to change, but the penalty for this should not lie with the already financially hard-pressed residents.
So, I ask again, has serious consideration been given to the required infrastructure to make these initiatives a long-term success?
If not, then surely a step back to reconsider the actual benefits to the residents and businesses in the area would be sensible.
Going back to basics and listing the pros and cons on a piece of paper might be all that is required to identify some potentially catastrophic decisions and avoid unnecessary pain for all and sundry.