Sally Allen: Campaigner to help Bay's hospital battle


Campaigner to speak to Torbay Heart campaigners
May has been an extremely busy month and what fabulous weather too. I find that good weather can always put a spring in your step, which was just as well as we have had a number of events taking place for the Torbay Civic Society including taking over 30 members around the new Indigo Hotel.
Then over the bank holiday weekend staging an open garden day at the glorious Wylam House with the National Gardening Scheme. It was frankly amazing. We had over 700 people come and view the beautiful gardens, including their Grade 2 listed rose garden.
It was extremely generous of Caroline and George Berg to welcome us and for also choosing our charity, the Torbay Civic Society, to take the opportunity to raise funds by supplying and serving refreshments, tea and coffee over the two days.
It was hard, but extremely enjoyable, work for our executive committee members and apart from raising money we also signed up a lot of new members in this picture-perfect environment.
Then on Friday, we had our normal monthly meeting at 10am at the Palace Theatre in Paignton, where Maureen and Clive are always a joy to work with and we had a very good turnout of members to hear Tim Jones, chief engineer of Torbay Council and Rachael Kiddey, strategic and culture lead, give us an update on the restoration of The Pavilion, Oldway and Torre Abbey.
It was extremely informative and interesting. This obviously all took place against the backdrop of the horrors of falling masonry off a landmark building in Paignton leading to a number of road closures.
This has obviously had, and will continue to have, a massive knock-on effect with traffic jams. Certainly our TCS members had to be resourceful in getting to our meeting and all the volunteers involved in raising funds for the Heart Campaign during the Riviera Airshow had to be equally imaginative in plotting their routes to enable them to get into position with their collection pots to raise as much money as possible towards our potential legal fees to mount a judicial review against the NHS. Volunteers are the backbone of every community, and ours in Torbay are outstanding.
This brings me on to exactly what is happening with the Heart Campaign saving Torbay Hospital. This Thursday June 4, we are staging a fundraiser at The Royal Torbay Yacht Club, which due to our fantastic volunteer army sold out in a heartbeat! Then extremely importantly on Wednesday June 24 we are having another public meeting at the Grand Hotel from 5pm with a prompt start at 5.30pm and our special speaker will be Mike Forster. So, a bit about this amazing man.
Mike Forster, a long-standing community campaigner in Huddersfield, became one of the leading figures in the fight to save Huddersfield Royal Infirmary from closure and downgrading during one of the most controversial NHS reorganisation battles in Yorkshire. As chair of the “Hands-Off HRI” campaign, he helped mobilise local residents, patients, healthcare workers and elected representatives against proposals by Calderdale and Huddersfield NHS Foundation Trust that would have seen major acute services transferred away from Huddersfield. Sounds familiar, well it should!
A crucial part of the campaign was the decision to challenge the NHS plans through the courts. Forster and fellow campaigners argued that the consultation process and decision-making behind the proposed changes were flawed.
They raised concerns about transport arrangements for patients, the availability of community care services, and legal duties that NHS organisations must follow under the UK’s equality laws when making major decisions such as hospital closures or service change had been properly considered. In essence this means that before changing or downgrading hospital services, the NHS must assess whether the proposals would unfairly disadvantage people such as elderly patients; disabled people; people without cars or access to public transport; poorer communities; pregnant women; ethnic minority groups; people with long-term illnesses.
The campaign also questioned claims about the condition of the hospital buildings, commissioning independent assessments that challenged assertions that the site could not remain in use for the future. So far, no doubt you will agree, a mirror image of what we are facing with Torbay Hospital.
In 2018, the campaign achieved a major breakthrough when it secured permission for a judicial review of the plans.
The judicial review helped delay and scrutinise the planned changes. Combined with sustained public pressure, political opposition and growing concerns about the practicality of the reorganisation, the challenge contributed to the eventual abandonment of plans to close Huddersfield’s full A&E department.
So, on 24th June Mike is coming to see how he can help and advise us on our next moves. One thing is for sure we will never give-up until the NHS agrees to keep a full service and acute status at Torbay Hospital. With all the thousands of new homes being built around Newton Abbot and Marsh Barton, the Royal Devon & Exeter Hospital and our own Torbay Hospital, need more money and services. Without the proper infrastructure for society, which means hospitals, roads and schools, these massive building initiatives are doomed. Does anyone do joined-up thinking in Whitehall?