Peter Moore: Who is working class nowadays?


Peter Moore puzzles over the Labour Party's difficulties over 'working people'
I blame Karl Marx for Keir Starmer’s confusion. He got completely tangled up when trying to define the working class (Keir Starmer, not Karl Marx). In fairness to Karl, he was writing in very different times.
His most important book, Das Kapital, was in three volumes written in 1867, 1885, and 1894. But society was different. The factory owners lived in large houses in the country, making large profits while the workers worked and lived in appalling conditions. Agricultural workers and tenant farmers also worked hard when the landowners made money. It is ironic that Marx’s collaborator on his book “The Communist Manifesto” and fellow left-wing radical was Friedrich Engels, whose wealthy father in Germany owned a textile mill.
Most people did not have the vote, and so government was the exclusive domain of the “ruling class”. MPs were not paid until 1911 so that someone from the “lower classes” could not afford to stand for parliament. The upper classes looked down their noses at anyone who was “in trade”. It was very clear who was working class.
Today’s world is very different. Who is “working class”? Who are “the workers”? There are very few aristocrats living off massive inheritances. Even the Duke of Westminster, who inherited his title and a £9 billion estate, worked as an account manager at a company turning coffee waste into bioproducts before inheriting his title. Does that make him working class?
Many traditional working-class jobs, such as coal mining, have disappeared. Factory work is often automated, meaning that many of the factory workers are highly skilled computer operators. There are still some jobs that simply require mundane work, such as pulling a lever, but far less than in Karl Marx’s day.
Are “tradesmen,” electricians, and plumbers working class? I know from friends that electricians have to pass difficult exams and keep up to date with the latest technology.
Today’s workers are often office workers spending their lives on computers. How far up the office hierarchy do we have to go to change from a worker to a boss?
The reason that politicians have become tangled up in the semantics of who is “working class” is that politics has become a bit like the Monty Python three Yorkshire men. Each one has to show that they worked their way up through a tough background.
If I were a politician (which I’m not), I would probably concentrate on my unsuccessful three weeks I spent working in a factory during my school holidays. The company made small transformers for toy racing cars. Transformers would appear on the conveyor belt, and I had to pick them up and put them in a press so that all the laminations would hold together. We had between 500 and 1,000 a day. It was so mind-numbingly boring that my mind wandered, and eventually I pulled the press without putting in the transformer and smashed the machine head. I was not popular.
Pay was poor, but I was told that there was a good bonus. At the end of the first week, I asked about the bonus and was told that students did not get the bonus. I resigned and spent the last week working very slowly. The whole industry has now moved to China, and the site of the factory is now a large NHS office block. Are all the NHS workers in these offices working class?
Today the only people who are not workers are either pensioners, like me, the disabled, or children. I am not sure that these are the “non-working” people the government wants to hit.
We need the best people in politics regardless of background. There is a risk that anyone from a highly privileged background does not understand the problems of “ordinary people.” But having spent over 30 years as a GP looking after “ordinary people,” I am still not sure what that means.
“Up the workers” is a great phrase on a march, but isn’t everyone who has a job a worker?