Peter Moore: We shouldn’t be focusing on Huw Edwards - we should be helping abused children


It may come as a surprise, but I do not always get everything right. On November 22, 2022 after the death of the Queen, I wrote: “My hero of the week must be Huw Edwards who managed a long shift presenting the change of Prime Minister and immediately presented the tragic news about the Queen. Surely, he’ll soon be Sir Huw Edwards.”
We now know that he had a terrible secret, downloading child pornography. Edwards argued that he had a difficult childhood with a ‘monstrous’ and ‘Puritanical’ father. He also felt inferior at the BBC as he failed to get into Oxford and ‘only’ went to Cardiff University.
Every excuse used by Huw Edwards could have applied to the impeccable John Humphrys. He was another top BBC journalist who also presented the main evening news. He was also from Wales. Unlike Huw Edwards he came from a working-class background. Although he passed the 11 plus and went to Grammar School he left at 15 as he did not fit into the middle-class environment. He did not go to any University but joined the Penarth Times as a junior reporter.
Through sheer talent he worked his way up, joined the larger Western Mail and then on to television. Throughout his stellar career there has never been any suggestion that he had a dark side. His background should have made him an outsider at the BBC but he became a part of the establishment.
Just like Edwards, other sexual offenders make dubious excuses. I am finding it difficult to understand the Frenchman Dominique Pelicot who drugged his wife and invited other men to rape her.
He also had a traumatic childhood including sexual abuse. When he finally apologised he added: “I am a rapist, like everyone else in this room”. No, this is not normal acceptable behaviour and no, not all other men are rapists.
In prisons and sometimes in General Practice I worked with paedophiles who have downloaded horrific images online although I am glad to say that I have never seen any of these images.
When caught the difficulty was working out whether these people have genuine remorse and realise the damage they caused or whether they were just remorseful because they had been caught.
When I carried out GP surgeries in Channings Wood Prison there was a defrocked priest who had been convicted of child abuse. He appeared to have no insight into the evil he had inflicted on children. He insisted on being called ‘Reverend’. All the staff made a point of calling him ‘Mr’.
Some abusers argue that they never touched a child, it was only pictures. This is no excuse. The pictures were of a real child and by downloading them they were encouraging the abusers. Downloading these images is child abuse.
This does not make the Internet inherently evil. The web should be viewed as a marketplace. In a marketplace there will be shops selling bibles, newspapers and other legitimate products but there may also be a drug dealer in the corner or someone selling pornography. That does not make the marketplace itself evil but does show that it must be properly policed.
But how can this be done? Are the social media companies doing enough to check their content? Do the algorithms take people down rabbit holes to dangerous content?
Although sexual offenders may well have some trauma in their past most people who have a traumatic childhood do not go on to commit sexual crimes. We all have free will.
If we are to prevent these evil crimes and protect our children we have to understand the perpetrators. That does not mean making excuses. I once met a forensic psychiatrist who was researching child sexual offenders. He was trying to understand their motivation with the aim of preventing these crimes. His problem, he told me, was that whenever he applied for a research grant and explained his aim was to help paedophiles the funding dried up.
Perhaps we should not be focusing on Huw Edwards. The people who really matter in this tragic story are the abused children.