Peter Moore - Warning: this article may inform debate

Sir Arthur Seymour Sullivan. Picture Credit: Wikiemediaplaceholder image
Sir Arthur Seymour Sullivan. Picture Credit: Wikiemedia

In Gilbert and Sullivan’s Ruddigore, premiered in 1887, one character, Rose Maybud, carries a book of etiquette wherever she goes. 

placeholder image

Gilbert (Picture credit: Wikimedia)

It was written by “no less a personage than the wife of a Lord Mayor”. Throughout the show she continuously refers to the book in every situation. Gilbert was taking the Mickey out of the many absurd conventions of the Victorians. Even the title of the opera became victim to Victorian prudery as it was initially called Ruddygore” but the word Ruddy was considered offensive. 

In an earlier show Gilbert shocked people by the line in HMS Pinafore “Damn-me it’s too bad”. For ladies to be prim and proper also meant sex was never mentioned but seen as a marital duty. Dr William Acton (1857) wrote “the majority of women (happily for them) are not very much troubled by sexual feelings of any kind.”

Contrary to the opinion of my grandchildren I was not brought up in the Victorian era but, in my childhood I would not have said “God” as an expletive in front of my parents even though they were not religious. Today the letters OMG appear in almost every text message.

In the 1960s the theatre critic Kenneth Tynan caused a major controversy by using the F word on TV. Now it is common after 9 O’clock. I also have a picture of a woman on the beach who was arrested in 1907 for her “obscene” costume. Although it is a bit tight, she is covered from head to toe. Today it would only raise eyebrows as covers rather more than the modern bikini.

But are we just as sensitive and prudish as our Victorian ancestors with different conventions? What rules would Rose Maybud’s book of etiquette have today?

Clearly the N word is not acceptable even though it was widespread in the past. This is mainly due to its implications in America and the legacy of slavery but it is racist and today this is a reasonable rule. The book of etiquette would also have to cover the thorny area of transgender. This new book of etiquette is clearly not one J K Rowling would have written. Someone who simply wants to debate whether a person with XY chromosomes can ever be a woman is “no platformed”. Suggesting that we should at least discuss the issues at it affects “women only spaces” and women’s sport is considered shocking. Is this any different from banning the word God as an expletive or any mention of sex? Anyone may agree or disagree on this difficult area, but the updated book of etiquette would ban any discussion.

Doubtless the new book of etiquette would have rules when to use trigger warnings. It is reasonable to warn anyone who might be epileptic if there is going to be strobe lights but trigger warnings are also used if a theatre production or television programme contains violence or obscenity. 

Some productions of Romeo and Juliet, King Lear and Hamlet have trigger warnings as they contain violence and suicides. Even Ruddigore has a scene where the portraits of ghosts come alive and step down from their picture frames to “torture” the new bad baronet, although being Gilbert and Sullivan they are not too serious. Isn’t the point of theatre to shock and surprise an audience? Does anyone going to see MacBeth or Romeo and Juliet really expect a happy ending?

Every generation has its idiosyncrasies. In Georgian times crying in public was normal but it was shocking to laugh in public. Before we accuse the Victorians of prudery are we any different? Isn’t it just that different things “shock us”? As a geriatric baby boomer I confess to getting confused. I once tried to book a “senior” ticket and asked whether they have a discount for us geriatrics. I was told firmly that the word “geriatric” is offensive even though I was talking about myself. Perhaps I should take offence and refuse to talk to myself. How can I avoid saying the wrong thing and causing offence? Perhaps it is time for a new addition of Rose Maybud’s book of etiquette.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice