Peter Moore: Time to take stock of today's 'poor laws'

placeholder image

One problem any new government has to face is the epidemic which followed Covid. There are 900,000 young people not in education, training or work. 269,000 households where no one has ever worked.

But how can we encourage thousands of people back to work while making sure that the genuinely disabled and sick are not pressurised?

This is not a new problem but goes back centuries. In 1495 King Henry VII passed the Vagabonds and Beggars Act, an Act which even today’s most right-wing politicians would find a bit harsh. This forced all 'vagabonds and idle persons' to be put in the stocks for three nights with only bread and water and then banned from the town. The situation was made worse when Henry VIII dissolved the monasteries who were providing help for the poor. The Vagabonds Act of 1530 gave the genuinely sick and disabled a licence to beg. We are still arguing about who is genuinely sick and disabled, but the modern welfare state does more than offer a licence to beg.

Still trying to solve the problem, Elizabeth I passed a Poor Law in 1551 which switched the responsibility for the poor and 'idle' on to the Parish. Today no one could imagine central Government ever passing the buck for difficult problems on to local Government. The problem with this act was that the money for poor relief had to be raised by 'overseers' in each parish who would 'gently ask' for donations. If someone was not convinced by being 'gently asked' they were sent to see the bishop. Not surprisingly this system did not always work. 

It was tightened up in 1562 when bishops were given the power to send someone to the justices if they would not pay. The justices then had the power to send them to jail. The flaw in the system was that it was up to the individual how much they paid.  I cannot imagine any government today asking taxpayers 'how much would you like to pay?' 

In 1572, when this was not working, justices of the peace were given the power to decide how much each parishioner should pay. This also tightened up on the vagabonds themselves. For a first offence they could be 'bored though the ear' which sounds a bit like some of the lectures I’ve been to over the years. Persistent offenders were hanged. This was also the first time that the idea of 'deserving and undeserving' poor was introduced. The punishments were only for able bodied men. Apparently, women did not work. These punishments were also given to workmen on strike, which would not help the NHS staffing crisis. It also applied to minstrels. After watching some of the contestants on Britain’s got Talent, this might not be a bad idea. 

In 1601 Elizabeth passed the Poor Law. Anyone unable to work because they were 'lame, impotent, old or blind' was cared for in an almshouse. Anyone who could work was set to work. 

Not much happened until 1832 when a Royal Commission was set up to review the working of the Poor Law. Here I have to declare an interest. It was chaired by my Great x 3 Grandfather, Bishop Blomfield, the Bishop of London. This led to the Poor Law of 1834 which set up workhouses. No relief could be given to anyone unless they entered the workhouse, and these were deliberately unpleasant so that the 'undeserving poor' could not sponge off the state. They did not even have a television or Wi-Fi. Even tougher than not having Sky TV in childhood. Workhouses were abolished in 1930 although the last one did not close until the NHS in 1948. It was tough and so, maybe I should not have mentioned my ancestor’s involvement.

So how should a modern government deal with the 'undeserving poor'? How can we assess whether someone is genuinely ill and needing support or just wants to be at home watching Homes under the hammer? As in previous centuries there is no easy answer. My ancestor may not agree but I would not suggest we send 900,000 young people not in education, training or work to the workhouse. 

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice