Peter Moore: The great grade debate - no need to panic!

placeholder image

To anyone who passed their A levels last week, congratulations, for those who were less successful, don’t panic, so was I the first time. 

Next year applications to university change. UCAS are dropping  the personal statement. Is this a good idea? It was an opportunity for students to demonstrate their skills at creative writing and total fiction. It demonstrated the potential students’ skill at giving a completely false impression by spinning a story, an excellent training for any future politician.

Luckily, when I applied just after the Norman conquest in 1066 personal statements were not needed. If I had written a personal statement, how would it read? 

“I decided to continue my studies for an extra year so that I could gain a deeper understanding of the subtleties of the subject” really meant that I failed my A levels the first time and had to re-sit. 

“I worked at the heart of the communication system in a large hospital ensuring that vital equipment was available.” I worked as a porter in a large mental hospital.

“I also worked in a major UK company ensuring that their customers had access to the leading products”. I was a shelf stacker in a supermarket. 

“I spent time caring for elderly vulnerable people often on a one-to-one basic”. I worked as a nursing assistant in a long stay geriatric hospital. 

But the most creative personal statements come from the wealthiest and most articulate privately educated students. “Whilst backpacking in Azerbaijan before bivouacking for the night I helped the locals round up their yaks and then used my solar powered laptop to write an essay on the importance of Plato in today’s society”. 

Personal statements benefit students from privileged backgrounds. This year 31.4 per cent of students at Oxford university went to a private school compared with 5.9 per cent of all students. Is this because public schools’ teachers and parents are more likely to help with the statement than someone from a more modest background? To make things worse today there is a risk that students could just ask AI to write the statement. 

In the past I interviewed applicants for the Torbay GP training scheme. These were qualified doctors hoping to join our scheme. 

Medical students have an “elective” when they can gain extra experience if approved by the University.  Some of my colleagues on the interview board were impressed if the applicant had visited far flung places and seen the world as a student. Although impressive I pointed but that there is no funding for electives. Anyone who had travelled to exotic places had been bankrolled by their family. A bright student from a comprehensive school brought up in social housing was just as competent as the wealthy student but never had that option. Here I admit to being biased. My mother was a widow and I spent my elective at that well known academic institution, Edgware General Hospital.

It is not only at medical school that the ability to bluff is an asset. I once helped a friend’s daughter write her university project. Although I knew nothing about media studies I have written and marked numerous projects over the years. I helped with construction and phraseology, and she got a first-class honours for the work. 

The new application forms will simply ask three questions, why do you want to study this course or subject, how have your qualifications and studies helped you to prepare for this course and what else have you done to prepare outside of education and why are these experiences helpful? There is still a risk that students from middle class backgrounds and public schools have an advantage. They may know which answers press the right buttons, but it might create a more level playing field.  Hopefully it will make it easier for astute admission’s tutors to see through the spin.

It was fortunate that I did not need a personal statement when I applied to medical school. Today it would not be a problem. I have spent forty years writing columns. What better training is there to learn creative writing and total fiction?

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice