Peter Moore: Snubbed! Where’s Devon on this ‘best’ list?


Newspapers love lists. The most popular lists are “the best hotels,” “the best pubs” and “best places to live”.
Recently “the best secret villages” was published in The Sunday Times. Besides the fact that plastering them across a national newspaper is not very secret there is also one glaring error. No village was listed between Constantine in West Cornwall and Blagdon in Somerset. Apparently, there are no beautiful secret villages in Devon. It is like listing the best music in the last 75 years and missing out The Beatles.
I have spent many happy hours driving around Devon villages with Devon Doctors on Call, and more recently visiting village halls to give talks to various Wis and other organisations. There are many beautiful villages with great communities even if the narrow roads can be challenging.
The problem with “the best” is that it is subjective. If Which Magazine lists the best sun creams or vacuum cleaners there is objective information. Does it reduce UVA and UVB, how well does it pick up dust? These things can be measured.
The best villages tried to measure criteria such as house prices, schools, location, the community and facilities but these depend on what you want. Low house prices are vital to a young family looking for their first home or single parent trying to scrape by but less important to a multimillionaire trying to downsize. If a village has a strong sense of community how long will it take an incomer to feel local?
I am sure the village of Whiteleaf in The Chiltern Hills is beautiful but not if you want to be near the sea.
Constantine in West Cornwall is amazing with an arts centre, good local restaurants and a local pub but not ideal for anyone who still commutes to London every day. For me it would be a long trip to Plainmoor and they do not even know that all scones must have cream first.
Apparently, there is a rule that any list of “the best” of anything must include Cornwall. It is where the wealthy from the southeast go on staycation or buy their holiday homes. I have nothing against my Cornish friends, but I have never understood why anyone would want to drive through the best county in Britain to cross the Tamar. In Devon we have also lost the propaganda battle with Cornish Cream and Irish Cider. In my childhood Devon was famous for both.
Maenclochog in Pembrokeshire has the advantage that, from the nearby Preseli Hills, you can even see Devon. That is an advantage but in Devon there is an even better view of Devon. Another advantage is that it is only 20 minutes to the sea. I think we can beat that, unless all the roads are being dug up again. I would have to live there several years before I could pronounce Maenclochog. Torbay is easier to pronounce although holidaymakers often mispronounce Hele and Shiphay.
Some of “the best places to live” are not realistic. A beautiful thatched cottage may look fantastic on a chocolate box but has anyone thought of the house insurance and general maintenance? It might even be listed making any improvements very difficult.
Where anyone wants to live is personal. Some people like to go walking and hiking, some want to be near music venues, some want to be near the sea and some want to be near family. There is no right or wrong.
Devon is a great place to live but we are one hundred miles to Bristol where the rest of the country starts. Cornwall is even further. Some of the best secret villages are even further from “civilisation” in the north of Scotland.
As a columnist I can see one huge advantage in publishing lists of the best places to live, best restaurants and best hotels. Along with many other people, I read it, and I am still talking about it. I suspect that is the main reason we are inundated with these lists.