Peter Moore: No more rosy specs – GP services are better than they've ever been


Some think that there are no real GP's anymore - Peter Moore thinks otherwise
There’s nothing like rose tinted glasses.
“GPs aren’t what they were. Remember the days when you could call your own GP, day and night.”
Until 2004 GPs were contracted to cover their patients twenty-four hours a day, 365 days a year. We could delegate to a colleague but it was still our responsibly. If anything went wrong we had to show that we had delegated to someone who was fully trained and competent. One Exeter GP had to face a complaint following an incident which occurred when he was on holiday in France.
In the 1980s we had a rota with two other local practices meaning I was on call about once a week. We also had a Saturday morning surgery which was not a part of a rota and so I ran a surgery alternate Saturdays.
When it was my turn any out of hours calls came through to my home. Before mobile phones I just drove around in our old 1983 Morris 1000. I had a fishing box in the boot which contained needles, syringe and intravenous drugs, including dimorphine (heroin). I was also working the next day. Looking back this was not only bad for my health and wellbeing but not good for the patients. Any visit at night was carried out after I had just been woken up and the following day I was seeing patients after I had been up all night. Was I really giving a wonderful service?
But did people in the 1980s complain that GPs aren’t what they were in the 1930s? One colleague whose father had been a GP before the War was told by his mother that the job was easier today. “Your father was always on call, not like today when you’re in a rota”. When he asked his father he admitted, “yes, technically we were always on call but if I had a visit in the middle on the country during the day I could do two hours fishing on the way out and another two hours on the way back”.
My grandfather was a GP in Newton Abbot. Like his partners he was a keen fisherman. When petrol was rationed he had a patient who lived near a good fishing river. On one of his numerous visits she said to him, “you’re a wonderful practice. You’re the third doctor I’ve seen today.”
By the year 2000 general practice had a problem. The next generation of doctors did not want to be a GP if it meant 24 hours responsibility. Many of the new GPs were married women with a family. The idea that GPs have always worked long hours on call was not a viable argument. Medical care had moved beyond an old car and a fishing box.
In 2004 the Government realised that general practice was in crisis. Without some way of improving the out of hours system no one would choose to be a GP. They had to change the system before there were no GPs. The contract was changed so that GPs were only responsible for their patients from 8am to 6pm.
We set up a not-for-profit company “Devon Doctors on Call” and employed receptionists and had cars with professional drivers. GPs were paid per shift but no shift was compulsory.
Under the old GP contract some of the funding was for the out of hours work. This money was taken away from GPs and used to pay for an out of hours service. It was soon discovered that the money allocated to GPs for out of hours under the old system was grossly inadequate. For years GPs had been underfunded for their out of hours work.
In 2022 Devon Doctors lost the contract and it has been run by the private company Practice Plus Group.
When reminiscing over the time when you could call out your own GP day or night remember it was not always “your GP” but another local doctor. This doctor might well be half asleep with minimal equipment. When you saw your own GP the next day they might have been up all night and a bit drowsy. Perhaps the out of hours service is a bit like my car. I became very fond of my old 1963 Morris but, if I am honest, my modern car is far more comfortable and reliable.