Peter Moore: Latest crackdown on smoking is welcome


When the smoking ban in pubs was announced in 2007 one man commented, “I have a serious chest problem. It will only get worse if I’m forced to go outside in the rain to smoke”.
I don’t think he understood irony. Now the Government have proposed a ban on smoking in pub gardens he will not even be able to go outside to smoke. As he had a severe chest problem in 2007 and continued to smoke, I suspect that he is no longer with us, and not because he stood out in the rain.
Banning smoking in pub gardens is in addition to Rishi Sunak‘s bill to ban selling tobacco products to anyone born after 1 st January 2009.
Smoking outside is less of a risk to others through passive smoking but the risk is still there. The other aim of the proposed legislation is to change the image of smoking. It needs to be seen as antisocial not macho.
When I was a student, the lecturer showed us an advert of a tough looking man with a cigarette standing by a horse being ridden by a gorgeous girl. “If he carries on smoking, he won’t be able to ride either” was the cynical comment.
When the government banned smoking in pubs and restaurants, I supported the move but thought it unrealistic. I am delighted to be wrong. Now the whole idea of smoking in pubs and restaurants seems bizarre. Why was it ever allowed?
Research published in the British Medical Journal found that there were 1,200 fewer heart attacks the following year, possibly from a reduction in passive smoking.
At the time many people in the hospitality industry were worried that it would spell the end of many pubs. This argument is now being revived against the ban on smoking in pub gardens. The smoking rate has fallen from 24 per cent in 2005 to just over 10 per cent now. Over six million people have given up smoking in a decade. Half as many middle-aged people are dying of lung cancer than 25 years ago.
Since smoking still kills about 80,000 people a year in the UK we must continue to cut smoking rates. Not only is each premature death a tragedy for the friends and family it will damage the economy. We are losing skilled people. Last year there were 400,000 smoking
related hospital admissions and an estimated £18 million in lost productivity.
There might be a loss of revenue for the treasury. Smokers pay an extra in taxes and many do not live long enough to collect their pension, but I am not sure that saving money by killing people is a strong economic argument.
Hopefully the image of smoking will change, especially amongst the young and here there is still a problem. This is one area where smoking rates might be increasing. In 2019 8.7 per cent of 16- and 17-year-olds said that they smoked cigarettes. Last year this rose to 12.2 per cent.
These figures are based on small samples and may not be accurate but seem to fit with the anecdotal evidence. Looking around I see more young people smoking than older people. Does this mean that many teenagers still see smoking as something grown up and tough? Telling someone of 16 that they might die at 50 will not worry them. When you’re 16, 50 is really old. But even if smoking is dangerous, adults shouldn't be allowed to make daft decisions. Is this proposed ban an attack on people’s freedoms?
As we all pay for the NHS smoking is costing all of us. Money spent on treating lung cancer in a smoker is not available for grandmother’s new hip. It is also costing the economy as we are losing skilled workers.
I hope this is another nail in the coffin of smoking if that is not an unfortunate metaphor. I look forward to sitting in the garden of a beautiful Devon country pub without having to look for a table where I can avoid secondhand smoke.